Blumer Dietrich, Montouris Georgia, Davies Keith
Department of Psychiatry, University of Tennessee, Memphis, TN, USA.
Epilepsy Behav. 2004 Dec;5(6):826-40. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2004.08.003.
The unawareness of psychiatrists about the importance of epilepsy dates back half a century, when epilepsy became considered an ordinary neurologic disorder. Epileptic seizures, however, can be provoked in every human being. Epilepsy is an extraordinary disorder that, beyond its well-known neurologic complexities, tends to become complicated with a wide range of specific psychiatric changes; they occur on the establishment of a temporal-limbic focus of intermittent excessive neuronal excitatory activity that produces increasingly inhibitory responses. These changes are distinct from those related to the two major psychiatric spheres for which a genetic basis is established, i.e., the manic-depressive and schizophrenic disorders, and represent a genetic sphere of its own. Apart from more subtle personality changes and the serious late complications of interictal psychoses and suicidal episodes, the key psychiatric syndrome associated with epilepsy consists of the interictal dysphoric disorder, with its characteristic intermittent and pleomorphic symptomatology. This disorder was clearly identified about a century ago by Kraepelin, when he established a comprehensive basis for the modern classification of the psychiatric disorders, at a time when epilepsy represented an area of major interest to psychiatrists. A practical method of recognizing the dysphoric disorder is reported. The disorder tends to be very treatable by combining psychotropic (chiefly antidepressant) with antiepileptic medication. The variations in treatment approach required are discussed and illustrated by representative case studies. Psychiatrists must become familiar with the psychiatric aspects of epilepsy to be able to assist the neurologists who focus on the neural complexities of the illness. They also must become able to recognize, among their own patients, the presence of a subictal dysphoric disorder that requires the same treatment as the interictal dysphoric disorder; combined treatment with antidepressant and antiepileptic medication is likewise indicated for the premenstrual dysphoric disorder, a condition that appears to belong to the spectrum of epilepsy-related psychiatric disorders. Furthermore, they must learn how an ignored population in their care, epilepsy patients confined to state hospitals, can be properly treated. Of particular importance is the need for psychiatrists to become familiar with the role of the paroxysmal affects in the general human condition, with their basic conflict to be intermittently angry and irascible yet otherwise good-natured, helpful, and religious--a conflict that tends to be particularly accentuated among patients with the "Sacred Disease."
精神科医生对癫痫重要性的忽视可追溯到半个世纪前,当时癫痫被视为一种普通的神经系统疾病。然而,癫痫发作在每个人身上都可能被诱发。癫痫是一种特殊的疾病,除了其众所周知的神经复杂性外,还往往会因一系列特定的精神变化而变得复杂;这些变化发生在间歇性过度神经元兴奋活动的颞叶边缘病灶形成时,这种活动会产生越来越多的抑制反应。这些变化与已确定有遗传基础的两个主要精神领域,即躁狂抑郁症和精神分裂症相关的变化不同,代表了其自身的遗传领域。除了更细微的人格变化以及发作间期精神病和自杀发作等严重的晚期并发症外,与癫痫相关的关键精神综合征包括发作间期烦躁症,其具有特征性的间歇性和多形性症状。大约一个世纪前,克雷佩林明确识别出了这种疾病,当时他为现代精神疾病分类奠定了全面基础,而在那个时候,癫痫是精神科医生主要关注的领域之一。本文报告了一种识别烦躁症的实用方法。通过将精神药物(主要是抗抑郁药)与抗癫痫药物联合使用,这种疾病往往很容易治疗。文中讨论了所需治疗方法的差异,并通过代表性病例研究进行了说明。精神科医生必须熟悉癫痫的精神方面,以便能够协助专注于该疾病神经复杂性的神经科医生。他们还必须能够在自己的患者中识别出需要与发作间期烦躁症相同治疗的发作期烦躁症;抗抑郁药和抗癫痫药物联合治疗同样适用于经前烦躁症,这种病症似乎属于与癫痫相关的精神疾病范围。此外,他们必须了解如何妥善治疗他们所护理的被忽视人群,即被限制在国立医院的癫痫患者。特别重要的是,精神科医生需要熟悉阵发性情感在一般人类状况中的作用,以及他们基本的冲突,即时而愤怒易怒,时而又脾气好、乐于助人且虔诚——这种冲突在患有“神圣疾病”的患者中往往会特别突出。