Ruchinskas Robert
Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Temple University Hospital, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19140, USA.
Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 2003 Apr;82(4):273-8. doi: 10.1097/01.PHM.0000056990.35007.C8.
To assess the ability of physical and occupational therapists engaged in rehabilitation of the elderly to predict posttreatment falls.
Prospective cohort study of 15 mo in duration at an urban academic medical center rehabilitation unit. A total of 165 consecutively admitted geriatric individuals were rated for fall risk by 14 physical and seven occupational therapists. Measurements included the Mini-Mental State Examination, Geriatric Depression Scale, FIM, and therapists' ratings of fall likelihood.
Both disciplines evidenced an ability to predict who would fall in the 3 mo after discharge. Clinical judgment regarding fall risk, however, added little value over two major predictors of future falls, fall history and the presence of a neurologic condition.
Trying to predict an infrequent future event such as falls is inherently difficult. Education regarding known fall-risk factors and inclusion of standardized measurements of physical status are recommended to potentially improve rates of detection, along with adoption of a realistic attitude regarding our abilities to forecast infrequent events.
评估从事老年康复治疗的物理治疗师和职业治疗师预测治疗后跌倒的能力。
在一家城市学术医疗中心康复科进行的为期15个月的前瞻性队列研究。14名物理治疗师和7名职业治疗师对165名连续入院的老年患者进行了跌倒风险评估。测量指标包括简易精神状态检查表、老年抑郁量表、功能独立性测量量表以及治疗师对跌倒可能性的评分。
两个学科均证明有能力预测出院后3个月内谁会跌倒。然而,关于跌倒风险的临床判断,相较于未来跌倒的两个主要预测因素——跌倒史和神经系统疾病的存在,增加的价值不大。
试图预测诸如跌倒等罕见的未来事件本质上是困难的。建议开展关于已知跌倒风险因素的教育,并纳入身体状况的标准化测量,以潜在地提高检测率,同时对我们预测罕见事件的能力采取现实的态度。