Jödicke Andreas, Hübner Felix, Böker Dieter-Karsten
Department of Neurosurgery, University Medical Centre, Justus-Liebig University, Giessen, Germany.
J Neurosurg. 2003 Mar;98(3):515-23. doi: 10.3171/jns.2003.98.3.0515.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of monitoring brain tissue oxygenation (PO2) during aneurysm surgery for the detection of procedure-related ischemia.
Between 1997 and 1998, PO2 was monitored prospectively in a cohort of 40 patients (42 recordings) during aneurysm surgery in the anterior circulation within the vascular territory of the aneurysm-bearing artery. The position of the probe used to measure oxygenation levels was verified on computerized tomography (CT) scanning on the 1st postoperative day. Because of the mislocation of one probe and the malfunction of another, data from only 38 patients (40 recordings) were suitable for analysis. Relative changes from baseline to absolute nadir values of intraoperative PO2 were correlated with simultaneously recorded somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEPs), and cardiovascular and ventilatory parameters. The frequency of ischemic events was evaluated with the aid of CT on the 1st postoperative day as a substitute parameter for intraoperative ischemia. Clinical outcome was evaluated 30 days postoperatively based on the Glasgow Outcome Scale. Except for three, all patients underwent surgery for treatment of a symptomatic aneurysm. Mean baseline PO2 was 23.9 mm Hg (range 2-67.2 mm Hg) before clip application. A relative decrease in PO2 (20% decrease in value compared with baseline) occurred in 12 patients and was a sensitive indicator for the risk of ischemia during temporary arterial occlusion, but was less predictive of nonocclusive ischemia (sensitivity 0.5; positive predictive value [PPV] 0.42; p > 0.05). Results of receiver operating characteristic analysis demonstrated a postclipping PO2 nadir of 15 mm Hg as a dichotomizing threshold for the prediction of ischemia. This threshold rendered an improved sensitivity (0.9) and PPV (0.56) for procedure-related ischemia (p = 0.0003). The results of utility analysis revealed this monitoring parameter to be clinically diagnostic. Only PO2 monitoring, and not SSEP at the tibial nerve, was predictive of ischemia within the anterior cerebral artery territory.
Using 15 mm Hg as a dichotomizing threshold, intraoperative PO2 monitoring enables one to identify patients at risk for procedure-related ischemia during aneurysm surgery and surpasses SSEP monitoring. This newly defined threshold based on intraoperative PO2 monitoring provides a basis for studies on treatments for procedure-related ischemia during aneurysm surgery.
本研究旨在评估在动脉瘤手术期间监测脑组织氧合(PO2)以检测与手术相关的缺血情况的可行性。
1997年至1998年期间,对40例患者(42次记录)在前循环动脉瘤手术期间进行前瞻性PO2监测,手术区域位于载瘤动脉的血管分布区内。术后第1天通过计算机断层扫描(CT)验证用于测量氧合水平的探头位置。由于一个探头位置错误和另一个探头故障,仅38例患者(40次记录)的数据适合分析。术中PO2从基线到绝对最低点值的相对变化与同时记录的体感诱发电位(SSEP)、心血管和通气参数相关。借助术后第1天的CT评估缺血事件的发生率,作为术中缺血的替代参数。术后30天根据格拉斯哥预后量表评估临床结局。除3例患者外,所有患者均接受有症状动脉瘤的手术治疗。夹闭前平均基线PO2为23.9 mmHg(范围2 - 67.2 mmHg)。12例患者出现PO2相对下降(与基线相比值下降20%),这是临时动脉闭塞期间缺血风险的敏感指标,但对非闭塞性缺血的预测性较差(敏感性0.5;阳性预测值[PPV] 0.42;p>0.05)。受试者工作特征分析结果表明,夹闭后PO2最低点为15 mmHg作为预测缺血的二分阈值。该阈值使与手术相关缺血的敏感性(0.9)和PPV(0.56)得到改善(p = 0.0003)。效用分析结果表明该监测参数具有临床诊断价值。仅PO2监测,而非胫神经SSEP,可预测大脑前动脉区域内的缺血情况。
以15 mmHg作为二分阈值,术中PO2监测能够识别动脉瘤手术期间与手术相关缺血风险的患者,且优于SSEP监测。基于术中PO2监测新定义的阈值为动脉瘤手术期间与手术相关缺血的治疗研究提供了基础。