Doll Corinne M, Milosevic Michael, Pintilie Melania, Hill Richard P, Fyles Anthony W
Department of Radiation Oncology, Princess Margaret Hospital, University Health Network and University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2003 Apr 1;55(5):1239-46. doi: 10.1016/s0360-3016(02)04474-7.
To define the minimal number of pO(2) measurements, with 90% sensitivity and 90% specificity, needed to categorize cervical tumors as either hypoxic or oxic.
Using Eppendorf oxygen probe data from our ongoing prospective trial, we simulated the measurement of tumor oxygenation with a smaller number of data points in 135 patients with cervical cancer. The hypoxic proportion, defined as the percentage of pO(2) values <5 mm Hg (HP5), was calculated for each tumor. Hypoxic tumors were defined as those with a median HP5 >50%, and tumors with normal oxygen levels as those with a median HP5 < or =50%. A small number of pO(2) measurements were randomly selected from the Eppendorf measurements in each tumor, or per Eppendorf track, and used to define the tumor as hypoxic or oxic. The sensitivity and specificity were calculated, considering the classification as given by the complete set of Eppendorf measurements as the reference standard.
The probability of falsely classifying the tumor decreased as the selected number of pO(2) measurements per tumor increased, and at 16 measurements was approximately 10%. Adding additional measurements per tumor beyond 24 improved the ability to classify the tumor accurately only slightly. The probability of falsely classifying the tumor decreased as the pO(2) measurements per track increased. At five measurements per track, the probability of falsely classifying the tumor was approximately 9%.
Approximately 20 measurements per tumor, or five measurements per track, using the Eppendorf pO(2) histograph, are sufficient to categorize cervical tumors as hypoxic or oxic. The results of this study will serve as a guide for research clinicians in the use of this and other systems in the assessment of tumor oxygenation in humans.
确定将宫颈肿瘤分类为缺氧或富氧状态时,所需的具有90%敏感性和90%特异性的最小pO₂测量次数。
利用我们正在进行的前瞻性试验中的Eppendorf氧探头数据,我们在135例宫颈癌患者中用较少的数据点模拟肿瘤氧合测量。计算每个肿瘤的缺氧比例,定义为pO₂值<5 mmHg的百分比(HP5)。缺氧肿瘤定义为HP5中位数>50%的肿瘤,氧水平正常的肿瘤定义为HP5中位数≤50%的肿瘤。从每个肿瘤或每个Eppendorf轨迹的Eppendorf测量值中随机选择少量pO₂测量值,并用于将肿瘤定义为缺氧或富氧。以Eppendorf测量的完整数据集给出的分类作为参考标准,计算敏感性和特异性。
随着每个肿瘤选择的pO₂测量次数增加,错误分类肿瘤的概率降低,在16次测量时约为10%。每个肿瘤增加超过24次的额外测量仅略微提高了准确分类肿瘤的能力。随着每个轨迹的pO₂测量次数增加,错误分类肿瘤的概率降低。在每个轨迹进行5次测量时,错误分类肿瘤的概率约为9%。
使用Eppendorf pO₂组织图,每个肿瘤大约20次测量或每个轨迹5次测量,足以将宫颈肿瘤分类为缺氧或富氧。本研究结果将为临床研究人员在使用该系统及其他系统评估人体肿瘤氧合方面提供指导。