Monke Holly J, Love Brenda C, Wittum Thomas E, Monke Donald R, Byrum Beverly A
Department of Veterinary Preventive Medicine, Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA.
J Vet Diagn Invest. 2002 Jan;14(1):35-9. doi: 10.1177/104063870201400107.
The combination of medium and growth conditions, including transport enrichment medium (TEM), transport time, TEM incubation time, and growth medium, that best support Campylobacter fetus subsp. venerealis while inhibiting contaminants was studied. The 3 TEMs evaluated, Weybridge, Cary-Blair, and 0.85% saline solution, were inoculated with preputial smegma spiked with C. fetus subsp. venerealis and held in the laboratory for 4 or 24 hours before inoculation onto growth medium. The effect of overnight incubation at 37 C of the TEM was also evaluated. Median scores of C. fetus subsp. venerealis growth and microbial contaminant inhibition were compared within TEM, transport time, overnight incubation, and growth medium groups using the Mann-Whitney U-test and the Kruskal-Wallis test. The proportion of samples with any growth or contamination within each group was also compared using the chi-square test. Results suggest that the growth of C. fetus subsp. venerealis was influenced by 3 of the 4 criteria evaluated. Weybridge TEM more effectively maintained the organism than did either Cary-Blair or 0.85% saline solution (P < 0.001). Transport time of 4 hours rather than 24 hours (P < 0.001) and avoiding overnight incubation of TEM at 37 C (P < 0.001) were associated with improved growth. Significant differences were not identified among growth media; however, Skirrow Campylobacter agar appeared to yield slightly better growth than did either blood agar or Greenbriar Plus agar. Contaminant growth was also influenced by 3 of the 4 variables. Weybridge TEM inhibited contaminant growth more effectively than did either Cary-Blair or 0.85% saline solution (P < 0.001). Transport time was not associated with contaminant growth. Eliminating overnight incubation of TEM reduced contamination (P < 0.01). Skirrow agar was preferred to both blood agar and Greenbriar Plus agar for suppression of contaminants on solid medium (P < 0.001). These results suggest that the detection of C. fetus subsp. venerealis is enhanced when preputial smegma samples arrive at the diagnostic laboratory within 4 hours after inoculation into Weybridge TEM and are transferred to Skirrow agar the same day they arrive in the laboratory.
研究了最有利于胎儿弯曲杆菌性病亚种生长同时抑制污染物生长的培养基和生长条件的组合,包括运输增菌培养基(TEM)、运输时间、TEM培养时间和生长培养基。对3种TEM(韦布里奇培养基、卡里-布莱尔培养基和0.85%盐溶液)接种添加了胎儿弯曲杆菌性病亚种的包皮垢,在接种到生长培养基之前在实验室保存4或24小时。还评估了TEM在37℃过夜培养的效果。使用曼-惠特尼U检验和克鲁斯卡尔-沃利斯检验比较了TEM、运输时间、过夜培养和生长培养基组内胎儿弯曲杆菌性病亚种生长的中位数评分和微生物污染物抑制情况。还使用卡方检验比较了每组中出现任何生长或污染的样本比例。结果表明,所评估的4个标准中的3个对胎儿弯曲杆菌性病亚种的生长有影响。韦布里奇TEM比卡里-布莱尔培养基或0.85%盐溶液更有效地保存该微生物(P<0.001)。4小时的运输时间而非24小时(P<0.001)以及避免TEM在37℃过夜培养(P<0.001)与生长改善相关。在生长培养基之间未发现显著差异;然而,斯基罗弯曲杆菌琼脂似乎比血琼脂或格林布里尔加琼脂产生的生长略好。污染物生长也受到4个变量中的3个的影响。韦布里奇TEM比卡里-布莱尔培养基或0.85%盐溶液更有效地抑制污染物生长(P<0.001)。运输时间与污染物生长无关。消除TEM的过夜培养减少了污染(P<0.01)。在固体培养基上抑制污染物生长方面,斯基罗琼脂比血琼脂和格林布里尔加琼脂更受青睐(P<0.001)。这些结果表明,当包皮垢样本在接种到韦布里奇TEM后4小时内到达诊断实验室,并在到达实验室当天转移到斯基罗琼脂上时,胎儿弯曲杆菌性病亚种的检测会得到加强。