Sridhar Raghunathan, Thach Bradley T, Kelly Dorothy H, Henslee Judith A
Division of Newborn Medicine, Department of Pediatrics, Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri 63110, USA.
Pediatr Pulmonol. 2003 Aug;36(2):113-22. doi: 10.1002/ppul.10287.
Our purpose was to identify and further characterize physiologic mechanisms relevant to autoresuscitation from hypoxic apnea in infants dying suddenly and unexpectedly. We studied cardiorespiratory recordings of 24 infants (age range, 0.8-21 months) who died suddenly while being monitored at home. These recordings were analyzed for features indicated by studies in animal models to be characteristic of hypoxic gasping, and of recovery from bradycardia and apnea associated with gasping (e.g., autoresuscitation). Findings in 5 infants diagnosed as having sudden infant death syndrome were compared with 6 non-SIDS infants whose deaths resulted from other conditions. Additionally, we studied 15 healthy infants during sleep, using home monitor and other respiratory recording techniques, in order to obtain comparison data. We found in recordings from 23 of 24 subjects that hypoxic gasps with characteristic features occurred immediately preceding death. A unique pattern of complex, closely spaced gasps ("double" or "triple" gasps) was present in many subjects. Evidence of partially successful autoresuscitation closely following one or more gasps occurred in 11 subjects, while another 4 had evidence of complete autoresuscitation with return of normal heart rate and resolution of apnea on one or more occasions. Significant differences between SIDS infants and those dying from other causes included increased occurrence of complex gasps and decreased occurrence of partial or complete autoresuscitation in the SIDS infants. The non-SIDS cases were different from the SIDS cases in that only one had "double" gasps (n = 7), while none had "triple" gasps, as compared with 4 out of 5 SIDS cases with these patterns (P < 0.05, chi-square). Also, in contrast with the SIDS cases, more of the cases with specific postmortem diagnoses had evidence of partial (5 out of 6 cases) or complete (1 out of 6 cases) autoresuscitation (P < 0.05, chi-square). We conclude that partial or complete autoresuscitation by gasping is not uncommon in moribund infants during the first year of life. Failure of autoresuscitation mechanisms other than failure to initiate gasping may be characteristic of infants dying of SIDS. Some SIDS infants appear to be different from infants dying with other diagnoses with respect to efficacy and characteristics of hypoxic gasping.
我们的目的是识别并进一步描述与婴儿突然意外死亡时缺氧性呼吸暂停自主复苏相关的生理机制。我们研究了24名在家中接受监测时突然死亡的婴儿(年龄范围为0.8 - 21个月)的心肺记录。对这些记录进行分析,以寻找动物模型研究中表明为缺氧喘息特征的特征,以及与喘息相关的心动过缓和呼吸暂停恢复(如自主复苏)的特征。将5名被诊断为婴儿猝死综合征的婴儿的研究结果与6名因其他情况死亡的非婴儿猝死综合征婴儿的结果进行比较。此外,我们使用家庭监测器和其他呼吸记录技术对15名健康婴儿在睡眠期间进行研究,以获取比较数据。我们发现在24名受试者中的23名的记录中,具有特征性的缺氧喘息在死亡前即刻出现。许多受试者存在一种独特的复杂、间隔紧密的喘息模式(“双重”或“三重”喘息)。11名受试者在一次或多次喘息后出现部分成功自主复苏的证据,另有4名受试者在一次或多次情况下有完全自主复苏的证据,即心率恢复正常且呼吸暂停消失。婴儿猝死综合征婴儿与其他原因死亡的婴儿之间的显著差异包括:婴儿猝死综合征婴儿中复杂喘息的发生率增加,部分或完全自主复苏的发生率降低。非婴儿猝死综合征病例与婴儿猝死综合征病例的不同之处在于,只有1例有“双重”喘息(n = 7),而无“三重”喘息,相比之下,5例婴儿猝死综合征病例中有4例有这些模式(P < 0.05,卡方检验)。此外,与婴儿猝死综合征病例相比,更多具有特定尸检诊断结果病例有部分(6例中的5例)或完全(6例中的1例)自主复苏的证据(P < 0.05,卡方检验)。我们得出结论,在生命的第一年,濒死婴儿通过喘息进行部分或完全自主复苏并不罕见。除了未能引发喘息外,自主复苏机制的失败可能是婴儿猝死综合征死亡婴儿的特征。在缺氧喘息的有效性和特征方面,一些婴儿猝死综合征婴儿似乎与有其他诊断的死亡婴儿不同。