Bajaj B K, Agarwal M P, Ram B Krishna
Department of Medicine, UCMS-GTB-Hospital, Shahdara, Delhi, India.
Postgrad Med J. 2003 Jul;79(933):408-11. doi: 10.1136/pmj.79.933.408.
Autonomic neuropathy has been reported in patients with alcoholic liver disease but information on its occurrence in patients with non-alcoholic liver disease is contradictory.
To assess autonomic functions in patients with alcoholic and non-alcoholic liver disease.
Autonomic function using five standard tests was examined in 20 cirrhotics (10 alcoholics and 10 non-alcoholics) and 20 age and sex matched controls. The extent of autonomic dysfunction was determined in the patients and a comparison between the characteristics of patients with and without autonomic neuropathy was made.
Sixteen (80%) of the cirrhotic subjects were found to have evidence of autonomic neuropathy. Of these, three (15%) patients had early parasympathetic damage, five (25%) had definite parasympathetic damage, and eight (40%) had combined (that is, both parasympathetic and sympathetic) damage. Nine (90%) of the alcoholics and seven (70%) of the non-alcoholics had autonomic dysfunction. Only one patient belonging to the alcoholic group had clinical evidence of peripheral neuropathy. Moreover, there was no significant association between subjective symptoms of autonomic neuropathy and objective evidence of autonomic damage as assessed by autonomic function tests. Autonomic dysfunction was significantly more frequent in advanced liver disease compared with early liver damage. Nine (75%) out of 12 cirrhotic subjects belonging to Child class B and six (85.7%) of the seven patients belonging to Child class C had autonomic neuropathy.
This study shows that autonomic neuropathy is common in cirrhotic subjects, that it is found with comparable frequency in alcoholics and non-alcoholics, and that it increases in severity with increase in extent of liver damage, suggesting that liver damage contributes to the neurological deficit.
酒精性肝病患者中已报告存在自主神经病变,但关于非酒精性肝病患者中其发生情况的信息相互矛盾。
评估酒精性和非酒精性肝病患者的自主神经功能。
使用五项标准测试对20例肝硬化患者(10例酒精性肝病患者和10例非酒精性肝病患者)以及20例年龄和性别匹配的对照者进行自主神经功能检查。确定患者自主神经功能障碍的程度,并对有和无自主神经病变的患者特征进行比较。
16例(80%)肝硬化受试者被发现有自主神经病变的证据。其中,3例(15%)患者有早期副交感神经损伤,5例(25%)有明确的副交感神经损伤,8例(40%)有联合(即副交感神经和交感神经均有)损伤。9例(90%)酒精性肝病患者和7例(70%)非酒精性肝病患者有自主神经功能障碍。仅1例酒精性肝病组患者有周围神经病变的临床证据。此外,自主神经病变的主观症状与自主神经功能测试评估的自主神经损伤客观证据之间无显著关联。与早期肝损伤相比,晚期肝病患者中自主神经功能障碍更为常见。12例Child B级肝硬化受试者中有9例(75%)以及7例Child C级患者中有6例(85.7%)有自主神经病变。
本研究表明,自主神经病变在肝硬化受试者中很常见,在酒精性和非酒精性肝病患者中出现的频率相当,并且其严重程度随肝损伤程度的增加而增加,提示肝损伤导致神经功能缺损。