Saunders Jimmy H, van Bree Henri
Department of Medical Imaging, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Ghent University, Salisburylaan 133, 9820 Merelbeke, Belgium.
Vet Radiol Ultrasound. 2003 Jul-Aug;44(4):414-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1740-8261.2003.tb00478.x.
To compare the radiographic and computed tomographic (CT) findings and to evaluate the sensitivity of radiography and CT for diagnosis of nasal aspergillosis in dogs, the radiographic and CT studies of 48 dogs with chronic nasal disease were reviewed separately. The radiographic and CT findings were recorded, and a diagnosis was made. The results obtained in the dogs with nasal aspergillosis (n = 25) were used. Based on definite aspergillosis as diagnosis, CT had a sensitivity of 88% and radiography of 72%. Considering definite and probable aspergillosis as equivalent, CT had a sensitivity of 92% and radiography of 84%. The sensitivity was higher in dogs with lesions affecting the entire nasal cavity and frontal sinus on at least one side (n = 20) with a sensitivity of 100% for CT and 90-95% for radiography than in dogs with lesions restricted to the nasal cavities (n = 5) where CT had a sensitivity of 60-80% and radiography of 0-40%. CT was superior to radiography for evaluation of the nasal cavities (mucosal thickening along the nasal bones, surrounding bone hyperostosis/lysis), frontal sinuses (mucosal thickening along the frontal bone, fluid/soft tissue, frontal bone hyperostosis/lysis), and differentiation between a cavitated-like or a mass-like process. This study suggests that CT is more sensitive than radiography for diagnosis of nasal aspergillosis in the dog because of a better demonstration of some changes suggestive of nasal aspergillosis. A diagnosis of a nasal aspergillosis restricted to the nasal cavities or associated with an FB is challenging, even with the use of CT.
为比较X线摄影和计算机断层扫描(CT)的检查结果,并评估X线摄影和CT对犬鼻曲霉菌病的诊断敏感性,我们分别回顾了48只患有慢性鼻病犬的X线摄影和CT检查结果。记录X线摄影和CT的检查结果并做出诊断。采用患有鼻曲霉菌病的犬(n = 25)所获得的结果。以确诊曲霉菌病作为诊断标准,CT的敏感性为88%,X线摄影为72%。若将确诊和疑似曲霉菌病视为等同情况,CT的敏感性为92%,X线摄影为84%。与病变局限于鼻腔的犬(n = 5)相比,病变累及至少一侧整个鼻腔和额窦的犬(n = 20)的敏感性更高,前者CT敏感性为60 - 80%,X线摄影为0 - 40%,而后者CT敏感性为100%,X线摄影为90 - 95%。在评估鼻腔(鼻骨周围黏膜增厚、周围骨质增生/溶解)、额窦(额骨周围黏膜增厚、液体/软组织、额骨骨质增生/溶解)以及区分空洞样或肿块样病变方面,CT优于X线摄影。本研究表明,由于CT能更好地显示一些提示鼻曲霉菌病的变化,因此在犬鼻曲霉菌病的诊断中,CT比X线摄影更敏感。即使使用CT,诊断局限于鼻腔或与异物相关的鼻曲霉菌病也具有挑战性。