Veale D, De Haro L, Lambrou C
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioural Sciences, Royal Free Campus, Royal Free and University College School of Medicine, University College, University of London, London, UK.
Br J Plast Surg. 2003 Sep;56(6):546-51. doi: 10.1016/s0007-1226(03)00209-1.
Body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) occurs in about 5% of patients seeking cosmetic surgery. Such patients are often dissatisfied with surgery or their symptoms of BDD are the same or worse after surgery. We report on a study that was designed to determine the frequency of BDD in patients requesting cosmetic rhinoplasty in the UK and to compare them with BDD patients in a psychiatric clinic. In the first stage of the study, we used a screening questionnaire for BDD and found that 20.7% of patients requesting rhinoplasty had a possible diagnosis of BDD. However, we believe that we identified a group of patients with sub-clinical or very mild BDD who are satisfied by cosmetic rhinoplasty. In the second stage of the study, we compared (a) patients without BDD who had a good outcome after cosmetic rhinoplasty with (b) BDD patients seen in a psychiatric clinic (who crave cosmetic rhinoplasty but for a variety of reasons do not obtain it). We found that BDD patients seen in a psychiatric clinic who desire cosmetic rhinoplasty are a quite distinct population from those obtaining routine rhinoplasty without symptoms of BDD. BDD patients are significantly younger, more depressed and anxious than this group, and are more preoccupied by their nose and check their nose more frequently. They are more likely to conduct "D.I.Y" surgery and have multiple concerns about their body. They are more likely to be significantly handicapped in their occupation, social life, and in intimate relationships and to avoid social situations because of their nose. They are therefore more likely to believe that dramatic changes would occur in their life after a rhinoplasty. This study provides some clues for surgeons who wish to identify patients with BDD who might have a poor prognosis in cosmetic rhinoplasty. Further research is required in the development of a screening questionnaire or interview for identifying patients with BDD seeking cosmetic surgery.
躯体变形障碍(BDD)在约5%寻求整容手术的患者中出现。这类患者往往对手术不满意,或者术后其BDD症状相同或更严重。我们报告一项研究,该研究旨在确定英国请求鼻整形术的患者中BDD的发生率,并将他们与精神科诊所的BDD患者进行比较。在研究的第一阶段,我们使用了BDD筛查问卷,发现20.7%请求鼻整形术的患者可能被诊断为BDD。然而,我们认为我们识别出了一组亚临床或非常轻度BDD的患者,他们对鼻整形术感到满意。在研究的第二阶段,我们比较了(a)鼻整形术后效果良好的无BDD患者与(b)精神科诊所的BDD患者(他们渴望鼻整形术,但由于各种原因未进行手术)。我们发现,精神科诊所中渴望鼻整形术的BDD患者与那些接受常规鼻整形术且无BDD症状的患者是截然不同的群体。BDD患者比这组患者明显更年轻、更抑郁和焦虑,对自己的鼻子更在意,且更频繁地检查鼻子。他们更有可能进行“自己动手”手术,对自己的身体有多种担忧。他们在职业、社交生活和亲密关系中更有可能受到严重影响,并因鼻子问题而避免社交场合。因此,他们更有可能相信鼻整形术后生活将发生巨大变化。这项研究为希望识别出在鼻整形术中预后可能较差的BDD患者的外科医生提供了一些线索。在开发用于识别寻求整容手术的BDD患者的筛查问卷或访谈方面,还需要进一步研究。