Sandstrom Marlene J, Cramer Phebe
Department of Psychology, Williams College, Bronfman Science Center, Williamstown, MA 01267, USA.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 2003 Aug;191(8):487-95. doi: 10.1097/01.nmd.0000082214.19699.6f.
The association between maturity of defense use and psychological functioning was assessed in a group of 95 elementary school children. Defense mechanisms were measured using a valid and reliable storytelling task, and psychological adjustment was assessed through a combination of parent and self-report questionnaires. Correlational analyses indicated that children who relied on the developmentally immature defense of denial reported higher levels of self-rated social anxiety and depression and received higher ratings of parent-reported internalizing and externalizing behavior problems. However, children who made use of the developmentally mature defense of identification exhibited higher scores on perceived competence in social, academic, conduct, athletic, and global domains. Significantly, there was no relationship between children's use of denial and their level of perceived competence or between children's use of identification and their degree of maladjustment.
在一组95名小学生中评估了防御方式的成熟度与心理功能之间的关联。使用一项有效且可靠的讲故事任务来测量防御机制,并通过家长和自我报告问卷的组合来评估心理调适情况。相关分析表明,依赖于发展不成熟的否认防御方式的儿童自我评定的社交焦虑和抑郁水平较高,并且在家长报告的内化和外化行为问题方面得到的评分也较高。然而,采用发展成熟的认同防御方式的儿童在社交、学业、行为、运动和整体领域的感知能力得分较高。值得注意的是,儿童使用否认防御方式与他们的感知能力水平之间没有关系,儿童使用认同防御方式与他们的适应不良程度之间也没有关系。