WAGLE P M, SEAL S C
Bull World Health Organ. 1953;9(5):597-614.
A comparison is made of the results obtained in various parts of India since 1945 with DDT, BHC, and Cyanogas in the control of plague.Antiplague campaigns involving the use of Cyanogas (calcium cyanide) have shown this pulicide to be effective in many cases in keeping down the flea index and in restricting the spread of the disease, although Cyanogas fumigation alone will not stop the annual recrudescence of epidemics. Comparative trials in Madras State showed that insufflation of rat-holes and harbourages with 10% DDT dusting-powder was effective in keeping the flea index below 1 in several villages, while repeated Cyanogas fumigation in the town of Coonoor did not greatly reduce the index there. In another series of experiments, the toxic action of both DDT and BHC (Gammexane) was still evident 84-90 days after dusting, but the DDT was the more powerful pulicide. Cyanogas dusting had no effect in reducing the flea index in these experiments.In their conclusions, the authors consider that DDT, despite a number of instances of its failure, is the most valuable pulicide, followed by BHC and Cyanogas, in that order. A successful antiplague operation, however, depends on the methods used, the dosage of pulicide, and the time and intensity of its application. In addition, to eradicate plague in endemic areas, it is, of course, necessary to continue control efforts during the interepidemic periods.
对1945年以来印度各地使用滴滴涕、六六六和氰化钙控制鼠疫所取得的结果进行了比较。涉及使用氰化钙的灭鼠运动表明,这种杀虫剂在许多情况下能有效降低跳蚤指数并限制疾病传播,尽管仅用氰化钙熏蒸并不能阻止疫情的年度复发。马德拉斯邦的对比试验表明,用10%的滴滴涕撒粉对鼠洞和藏身处进行喷粉,在几个村庄能有效地将跳蚤指数控制在1以下,而在库努尔镇反复进行氰化钙熏蒸,那里的跳蚤指数并没有大幅降低。在另一系列实验中,撒粉84 - 90天后,滴滴涕和六六六(林丹)的毒性作用仍然明显,但滴滴涕是更有效的杀虫剂。在这些实验中,氰化钙喷粉对降低跳蚤指数没有效果。作者在结论中认为,尽管滴滴涕有许多失败的例子,但它仍是最有价值的杀虫剂,其次是六六六和氰化钙,顺序依次如此。然而,一次成功的灭鼠行动取决于所使用的方法、杀虫剂的剂量以及施用的时间和强度。此外,要在疫区根除鼠疫,当然有必要在疫情间歇期继续进行防治工作。