Sung Paul S
Iowa Spine Research Center, Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242, USA.
Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2003 Sep;84(9):1313-8. doi: 10.1016/s0003-9993(03)00139-4.
To determine changes in multifidi muscle endurance and functional status after a 4-week spinal stabilization exercise program for patients presenting with chronic low back dysfunction (LBD).
Short-term longitudinal cohort study.
A rehabilitation facility.
Sixteen patients (10 men, 6 women) with chronic LBD.
Patients were evaluated pre- and posttreatment for outcomes of functional status and muscle fatigue. Treatment consisted of patients participating in supervised spinal stabilization exercises 3 times a week over a 4-week period. Main outcome measures Oswestry Low Back Pain Disability Questionnaire and muscle fatigue based on electromyographically based median frequency assessed during the first 4 seconds and the last 4 seconds of a modified 1-minute Sorenson test.
Oswestry scores improved significantly from pre- to posttreatment (22.9 vs 18.3, P<.027). A significant treatment by gender interaction (P<.031) indicated significant pre- to posttreatment loss of endurance for men (149.3 vs 143.2, P<.045) and a slight, but not statistically significant increase in endurance for women (110.7 vs. 115.5, P<.20).
A 4-week spinal stabilization exercise program significantly improved functional status in patients presenting with LBD. However, a significant pre- to posttreatment increase in multifidi muscle fatigue for men (P<.045) coupled with a nonsignificant improvement in multifidi muscle endurance for women (P<.20) was unexpected; this may reflect an insufficiency of a 4-week program to effect muscle fatigue or a lack of sensitivity of electromyographically based median frequency as the method for assessing muscle endurance. Additional randomized controlled trials to more fully investigate treatment effects and factors that may mediate these effects are needed.
确定针对慢性下背部功能障碍(LBD)患者进行为期4周的脊柱稳定锻炼计划后,多裂肌耐力和功能状态的变化。
短期纵向队列研究。
一家康复机构。
16例慢性LBD患者(10名男性,6名女性)。
在治疗前后对患者进行功能状态和肌肉疲劳结果评估。治疗包括患者在4周内每周参加3次有监督的脊柱稳定锻炼。主要结局指标为Oswestry下背痛残疾问卷以及基于改良1分钟索伦森测试前4秒和后4秒肌电图中位频率评估的肌肉疲劳。
从治疗前到治疗后,Oswestry评分显著改善(22.9对18.3,P<.027)。性别交互作用的显著治疗效果(P<.031)表明,男性治疗前到治疗后耐力显著下降(149.3对143.2,P<.045),而女性耐力略有增加但无统计学意义(110.7对115.5,P<.20)。
为期4周的脊柱稳定锻炼计划显著改善了LBD患者的功能状态。然而,男性治疗前到治疗后多裂肌疲劳显著增加(P<.045),而女性多裂肌耐力改善不显著(P<.20),这出乎意料;这可能反映了4周计划对影响肌肉疲劳的不足,或者基于肌电图的中位频率作为评估肌肉耐力方法的敏感性不足。需要更多的随机对照试验来更全面地研究治疗效果以及可能介导这些效果的因素。