Weinans H, Huiskes R, Grootenboer H J
Biomechanics Section, University of Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
J Orthop Res. 1992 Nov;10(6):845-53. doi: 10.1002/jor.1100100614.
Bone loss around femoral hip stems is one of the problems threatening the long-term fixation of uncemented stems. Many believe that this phenomenon is caused by reduced stresses in the bone (stress shielding). In the present study the mechanical consequences of different femoral stem materials were investigated using adaptive bone remodeling theory in combination with the finite element method. Bone-remodeling in the femur around the implant and interface stresses between bone and implant were investigated for fully bonded femoral stems. Cemented stems (cobalt-chrome or titanium alloy) caused less bone resorption and lower interface stresses than uncemented stems made from the same materials. The range of the bone resorption predicted in the simulation models was from 23% in the proximal medial cortex surrounding the cemented titanium alloy stem to 76% in the proximal medial cortex around the uncemented cobalt-chrome stem. Very little bone resorption was predicted around a flexible, uncemented "iso-elastic" stem, but the proximal interface stresses increased drastically relative to the stiffer uncemented stems composed of cobalt-chrome or titanium alloy. However, the proximal interface stress peak was reduced and shifted during the adaptive remodeling process. The latter was found particularly in the stiffer uncemented cobalt-chrome-molybdenum implant and less for the flexible iso-elastic implant.
股骨柄周围的骨质流失是威胁非骨水泥柄长期固定的问题之一。许多人认为这种现象是由骨内应力降低(应力遮挡)引起的。在本研究中,结合有限元方法,运用适应性骨重塑理论研究了不同股骨柄材料的力学后果。对于完全粘结的股骨柄,研究了植入物周围股骨的骨重塑以及骨与植入物之间的界面应力。与由相同材料制成的非骨水泥柄相比,骨水泥柄(钴铬合金或钛合金)引起的骨吸收更少,界面应力更低。模拟模型预测的骨吸收范围从骨水泥钛合金柄周围近端内侧皮质的23%到非骨水泥钴铬合金柄周围近端内侧皮质的76%。预计在柔性非骨水泥“等弹性”柄周围骨吸收很少,但相对于由钴铬合金或钛合金制成的较硬非骨水泥柄,近端界面应力急剧增加。然而,在适应性重塑过程中,近端界面应力峰值降低并发生了偏移。后者在较硬的非骨水泥钴铬钼植入物中尤为明显,而在柔性等弹性植入物中则较少。