KASI A M
Bull World Health Organ. 1964;30(5):631-4.
In 1960, some 72 000 schoolchildren in British Guiana participated in a controlled field trial of typhoid fever vaccines that was supported in part by the World Health Organization. The children were divided into three groups each receiving two doses, one of acetone-dried and inactivated vaccine, the second of heat-phenol-inactivated vaccine, and the third (control group) of tetanus toxoid. They were followed up over 3 1/2 years, during which time 99 cases of typhoid fever occurred in the control group, 6 in the acetone-dried vaccine group, and 26 in the heat-phenol vaccine group. Attack rates of the same order of magnitude were observed among 10 000 other children divided into the same three groups but given only one inoculation.The vaccines used were the same as those tested in a similar trial in Yugoslavia, and, although the attack rates in British Guiana were considerably lower in all groups than those in Yugoslavia, the findings in the two trials are in general agreement and indicate that acetone-dried vaccine confers greater protection than vaccine prepared from the same strains but inactivated by heat-phenol.
1960年,英属圭亚那约7.2万名学童参与了一场伤寒疫苗对照现场试验,该试验部分得到了世界卫生组织的支持。这些儿童被分为三组,每组接种两剂疫苗,一组接种丙酮干燥灭活疫苗,第二组接种热酚灭活疫苗,第三组(对照组)接种破伤风类毒素。对他们进行了3年半的随访,在此期间,对照组出现了99例伤寒病例,丙酮干燥疫苗组出现了6例,热酚疫苗组出现了26例。在另外1万名被分为相同三组但只接种一剂疫苗的儿童中,也观察到了相同数量级的发病率。所使用的疫苗与在南斯拉夫进行的一项类似试验中测试的疫苗相同,尽管英属圭亚那所有组的发病率都远低于南斯拉夫,但两项试验的结果总体一致,表明丙酮干燥疫苗比用相同菌株但经热酚灭活制备的疫苗具有更强的保护作用。