Bull World Health Organ. 1966;34(2):211-22.
In recent years studies of the effectiveness of different typhoid vaccines have been sponsored by the World Health Organization in British Guiana, the USSR, and Yugoslavia. A similarly sponsored study has been made in Poland under the auspices of the Polish Typhoid Committee. In the controlled field trial four types of vaccine were used: (1) bacterial acetone-killed and -dried (vaccines K and P), (2) bacterial formol-killed phenol-preserved (vaccine N), (3) Westphal's endotoxin adsorbed on aluminium hydroxide (vaccine S), and (4) Grasset's vaccine (autolysate of typhoid bacilli adsorbed on aluminium hydroxide; vaccine T). The control vaccine was tetanus toxoid (vaccine O). Laboratory tests were also carried out.In children aged 5-14 years who received two inoculations, vaccine N was the most effective, followed by K; vaccine T was distinctly less effective. In people aged 15-60 years the small number of typhoid cases made evaluation difficult; however, vaccines N and P inoculated once afforded protection, whereas vaccine S imparted none.FURTHER STUDIES ARE DESIRABLE ON THE LABORATORY TESTING OF TYPHOID VACCINES: at present the H and O agglutination tests with sera of immunized rabbits, combined with an active mouse-protection test, can be recommended, provided that a standard typhoid vaccine is used for comparison.
近年来,世界卫生组织在英属圭亚那、苏联和南斯拉夫开展了不同伤寒疫苗有效性的研究。在波兰伤寒委员会的主持下,也进行了一项类似的研究。在对照现场试验中,使用了四种类型的疫苗:(1)细菌丙酮灭活干燥疫苗(疫苗K和P),(2)细菌甲醛灭活苯酚保存疫苗(疫苗N),(3)吸附于氢氧化铝的韦斯特法尔内毒素疫苗(疫苗S),以及(4)格拉塞疫苗(吸附于氢氧化铝的伤寒杆菌自溶物;疫苗T)。对照疫苗为破伤风类毒素(疫苗O)。还进行了实验室检测。在5至14岁接受两次接种的儿童中,疫苗N最有效,其次是疫苗K;疫苗T明显效果较差。在15至60岁的人群中,伤寒病例数量较少,难以进行评估;然而,接种一次疫苗N和P可提供保护,而疫苗S则无此效果。关于伤寒疫苗的实验室检测,需要进一步研究:目前,建议使用免疫兔血清进行H和O凝集试验,并结合活性小鼠保护试验,前提是使用标准伤寒疫苗进行比较。