Dowell M E, Ross P G, Musher D M, Cate T R, Baughn R E
Infectious Disease Section, Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Houston, Texas 77030.
Am J Med. 1992 Nov;93(5):481-8. doi: 10.1016/0002-9343(92)90574-u.
To evaluate the effect of ceftriaxone in treating latent syphilis or asymptomatic neurosyphilis in patients infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV).
Follow-up study of patients treated at two HIV-based clinics during 16 months from 1989 to 1991.
Patients were those in whom a clinical diagnosis of latent syphilis or asymptomatic neurosyphilis was made, who received all recommended doses of antimicrobial therapy, and who returned for follow-up visits for 6 or more months.
Forty-three patients were treated with ceftriaxone, 1 to 2 g daily for 10 to 14 days. Thirteen underwent lumbar puncture before treatment; 7 (58%) had documented neurosyphilis (pleocytosis in 5, elevated protein levels in 6, VDRL reactive in cerebrospinal fluid [CSF] in 7), and 6 had documented latent syphilis (entirely normal CSF). The remaining 30 were said to have presumed latent syphilis. There was no relation between the diagnosis and the selected dosage of ceftriaxone. Response rates were similar in those who had documented neurosyphilis and documented or presumed latent syphilis. Overall, 28 patients (65%) responded to therapy, 5 (12%) were serofast, 9 (21%) had a serologic relapse, and 1 (2%) who experienced progression to symptomatic neurosyphilis was a therapeutic failure. Thirteen patients received benzathine penicillin for presumed latent syphilis; results were similar to those observed after ceftriaxone therapy, with 8 (62%) responders, 1 (8%) serofast, 2 (15%) relapses, and 2 (15%) failures. CD4 cell counts in responders were not different from those who failed to respond.
Even in the absence of neurologic symptoms, half of the HIV-infected persons who have serologic evidence of syphilis may have neurosyphilis. Although ceftriaxone achieves high serum and CSF levels, 10 to 14 days of treatment with this drug were associated with a 23% failure rate in HIV-infected patients who had latent syphilis or asymptomatic neurosyphilis. Three doses of benzathine penicillin did not have a significantly higher relapse rate and may provide appropriate therapy, at least for documented latent syphilis in persons co-infected with HIV. Studies comparing ceftriaxone with 10 to 14 doses of procaine penicillin are needed to determine the most cost-effective treatment for asymptomatic neurosyphilis or presumed latent syphilis in this group of patients.
评估头孢曲松治疗感染人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)患者的潜伏梅毒或无症状神经梅毒的效果。
对1989年至1991年期间在两家以HIV为基础的诊所接受治疗的患者进行随访研究。
临床诊断为潜伏梅毒或无症状神经梅毒,接受了所有推荐剂量抗菌治疗,并返回进行6个月或更长时间随访的患者。
43例患者接受头孢曲松治疗,每日1至2克,持续10至14天。13例在治疗前进行了腰椎穿刺;7例(58%)确诊为神经梅毒(5例有细胞增多,6例蛋白水平升高,7例脑脊液[CSF]梅毒血清学反应阳性),6例确诊为潜伏梅毒(脑脊液完全正常)。其余30例被认为患有潜伏梅毒。诊断与所选头孢曲松剂量之间无关联。确诊神经梅毒以及确诊或疑似潜伏梅毒的患者的反应率相似。总体而言,28例患者(65%)对治疗有反应,5例(12%)血清固定,9例(21%)血清学复发,1例(2%)进展为有症状神经梅毒,治疗失败。13例疑似潜伏梅毒患者接受了苄星青霉素治疗;结果与头孢曲松治疗后观察到的结果相似,8例(62%)有反应,1例(8%)血清固定,2例(15%)复发,2例(15%)治疗失败。有反应者的CD4细胞计数与无反应者无差异。
即使没有神经系统症状,有梅毒血清学证据的HIV感染者中,一半可能患有神经梅毒。尽管头孢曲松在血清和脑脊液中能达到较高水平,但对于患有潜伏梅毒或无症状神经梅毒的HIV感染患者,使用该药治疗10至14天的失败率为23%。三剂苄星青霉素的复发率没有显著更高,可能提供合适的治疗,至少对于HIV合并感染患者的确诊潜伏梅毒是如此。需要进行头孢曲松与10至14剂普鲁卡因青霉素的比较研究,以确定该组患者无症状神经梅毒或疑似潜伏梅毒的最具成本效益的治疗方法。