Cooper Richard A
Health Policy Institute, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53226, USA.
Acad Med. 2003 Sep;78(9):864-76. doi: 10.1097/00001888-200309000-00004.
The availability of sufficient numbers of qualified medical school applicants has been a periodic source of concern. Over the past few years, this concern has emerged again, as fewer men have applied to medical school and as the number of minority applicants has stagnated. This time, however, the cause for concern is greater, because these declining numbers coincide with a growing need for physicians and the possibility that medical school capacity will have to be expanded to avert future physician shortages. Against this background, applications by members of racial and ethnic minorities, who represent an increasing fraction of the college age population, become particularly important. The author reports the trends in education, over several decades, by members of the principal racial-ethnic groups-whites, blacks, Hispanics, and Asians-traces their participation from kindergarten through college, and projects the likelihood of their applying to medical school over the next two decades. (A companion article in this issue reports a parallel study from the standpoint of gender.) One prominent observation is the firm link between academic achievement in the earliest grades and success thereafter. A second is the profound influence of parents' education, income, and expectations at each step along the way. Inadequacies in either sphere erode the potential for children to reach college and to do so in ways that predict interest in and capacity for medical school. Yet, even when that potential emerges, inadequate finances deflect qualified high school and college students from the paths that lead to medical education. These factors weigh most heavily on black and Hispanic children, particularly boys, but are prevalent among whites, as well. Without aggressive education in the earliest years and without adequate financial support in the later years, it is not clear that there will be a sufficiently large pool of qualified applicants for the number of medical school seats that must exist in the future.
有足够数量的合格医学院申请者,一直是一个周期性令人担忧的问题。在过去几年里,这种担忧再度出现,因为申请医学院的男性人数减少,以及少数族裔申请者的数量停滞不前。然而,这次令人担忧的原因更加严重,因为这些不断下降的数字与对医生日益增长的需求相吻合,而且医学院可能需要扩大规模以避免未来出现医生短缺的情况。在这种背景下,占大学适龄人口比例越来越大的种族和族裔少数群体成员的申请变得尤为重要。作者报告了几十年来主要种族和族裔群体(白人、黑人、西班牙裔和亚裔)成员的教育趋势,追溯了他们从幼儿园到大学的参与情况,并预测了他们在未来二十年申请医学院的可能性。(本期的一篇配套文章从性别的角度报道了一项类似的研究。)一个突出的观察结果是,早期成绩与之后的成功之间有着紧密的联系。第二个观察结果是,父母在孩子成长的每一步所接受的教育、收入和期望都有着深远的影响。这两个方面的不足都会削弱孩子上大学的潜力,以及以预示着对医学院感兴趣并有能力进入医学院的方式上大学的潜力。然而,即使这种潜力显现出来,资金不足也会使合格的高中生和大学生偏离通往医学教育的道路。这些因素对黑人和西班牙裔儿童,尤其是男孩影响最大,但在白人中也很普遍。如果早年没有积极的教育,晚年没有足够的经济支持,未来是否会有足够多的合格申请者来填补医学院必须设置的名额尚不清楚。