Mehni Sareh, Keshavarzi Mohhammad Hasan, Faghihi Seyed AliAkbar, Dehnavieh Tijang Reza
Clinical Education Research Center, School of Medicine, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran.
Department of Midwifery, School of Nursing and Midwifery Jiroft University of Medical Sciences, Jiroft, Iran.
Med J Islam Repub Iran. 2025 Jan 15;39:9. doi: 10.47176/mjiri.39.9. eCollection 2025.
Among various types of leadership, educational leadership has established a privileged position for itself. This is attributable to its major contribution to effective learning and teaching processes, along with changes in social structures and ideas. Recent studies have underscored the educational leaders' pivotal role in organizational success. In addition, the literature highlights various factors-including environmental and social influences-that impact leaders' performance. The present study aimed to identify and categorize the factors and parameters influencing the performance of educational leaders within the medical education setting.
This study adopts a scoping review approach, akin to a systematic review but with slight differences in the comprehensive search and quality assessment procedures. Medline, Embase, APA PsycINFO, Scopus, Web of Science, and CINAHL ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Completed were searched using advanced search options and Boolean operators "AND" and "OR" to retrieve the most relevant records.
Of the total records obtained from 6081 online data sources, after removing duplicates and the records featuring irrelevant titles, abstracts, titles, or full papers, 17 articles were chosen for data extraction. We analyzed the challenges faced by educational leaders across 5 primary categories-organizational structure, human resources, education system, leadership characteristics, and external factors.
Leaders in medical education operate in a complex system that includes academic settings, health care organizations, and other regulatory and professional bodies. Medical education institutions must help address the critical needs of leaders and leadership development. It is suggested that the developments in the field of academic leadership should be founded based on the following threeelements-knowledge and individual leadership skills, organizational improvement, and strategic position of the organization.
在各类领导方式中,教育领导已为自身确立了特殊地位。这归因于它对有效学习和教学过程的重大贡献,以及社会结构和观念的变化。近期研究强调了教育领导者在组织成功中的关键作用。此外,文献突出了包括环境和社会影响在内的各种影响领导者绩效的因素。本研究旨在识别和分类影响医学教育环境中教育领导者绩效的因素和参数。
本研究采用范围综述方法,类似于系统综述,但在全面检索和质量评估程序上略有不同。使用高级检索选项以及布尔运算符“AND”和“OR”在Medline、Embase、APA PsycINFO、Scopus、Web of Science和CINAHL ProQuest学位论文全文数据库中进行检索,以获取最相关的记录。
从6081个在线数据源获得的所有记录中,去除重复记录以及标题、摘要、标题或全文不相关的记录后,选择了17篇文章进行数据提取。我们分析了教育领导者面临的挑战,分为组织结构、人力资源、教育系统、领导特征和外部因素5个主要类别。
医学教育领域的领导者在一个复杂的系统中运作,该系统包括学术环境、医疗保健组织以及其他监管和专业机构。医学教育机构必须帮助满足领导者和领导力发展的关键需求。建议学术领导领域的发展应基于以下三个要素——知识和个人领导技能、组织改进以及组织的战略地位。