Dowson J H
Department of Psychiatry, University of Cambridge, UK.
Compr Psychiatry. 1992 Nov-Dec;33(6):397-406. doi: 10.1016/0010-440x(92)90062-u.
Modified versions of the revised Personality Diagnostic Questionnaire (PDQ-R) for DSM-III-R personality disorders (PDs) were completed by 60 patients and their informants. Patients' ratings gave a mean number of 4.5 PDs per subject and narcissistic (NAR) PD in 42%. Informants' ratings gave NAR PD in 38%. For patients and informants, NAR PD scores (i.e., the number of positive NAR PD criteria for each subject) were significantly correlated with histrionic (HIS) and borderline (BOR) PD scores and with scores of some PDs outside DSM-III-R's "cluster B." Also, there were significant correlations between patients' and informants' NAR PD scores and between NAR PD scores and total number of positive criteria (i.e., for all 13 PDs) for patients and informants. For patients' ratings, there were significant associations between NAR PD and HIS, BOR, and passive-aggressive (PAG) PDs and, for informants' ratings, between NAR and HIS PDs. There was no significant association between patients' and informants' diagnoses of NAR PD. Grandiosity, the most characteristic feature of narcissism, is related to NAR PD criteria 3 through 6. The patients' evaluation of criterion 6 (i.e., "Has a sense of entitlement ...") shows satisfactory item-total correlation and endorsement frequency, together with "fair to good" reliability when patients' and informants' ratings are compared (kappa = 0.62). The identification of a sense of entitlement by the patient may be a relatively reliable and valid indicator of narcissism.
60名患者及其提供信息者完成了针对《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版修订本(DSM-III-R)人格障碍(PD)的修订版人格诊断问卷(PDQ-R)。患者自评显示,每位受试者平均有4.5种人格障碍,42%的患者患有自恋型(NAR)人格障碍。提供信息者的评定显示,38%的患者患有自恋型人格障碍。对于患者和提供信息者而言,自恋型人格障碍得分(即每位受试者自恋型人格障碍阳性标准的数量)与表演型(HIS)和边缘型(BOR)人格障碍得分以及DSM-III-R“B组”之外的某些人格障碍得分显著相关。此外,患者和提供信息者的自恋型人格障碍得分之间、自恋型人格障碍得分与患者和提供信息者的阳性标准总数(即所有13种人格障碍)之间存在显著相关性。对于患者自评,自恋型人格障碍与表演型、边缘型和被动攻击型(PAG)人格障碍之间存在显著关联;对于提供信息者的评定,自恋型人格障碍与表演型人格障碍之间存在显著关联。患者和提供信息者对自恋型人格障碍的诊断之间没有显著关联。夸大是自恋最典型的特征,与自恋型人格障碍标准3至6相关。患者对标准6(即“有权利感……”)的评价显示,项目总分相关性和认可频率令人满意,在比较患者和提供信息者的评定时,信度为“中等偏上”(kappa = 0.62)。患者对权利感的识别可能是自恋相对可靠且有效的指标。