Ryder Andrew G, McBride Carolina, Bagby R Michael
Department of Psychology, Concordia University, Montreal, QC.
J Pers Disord. 2008 Apr;22(2):208-16. doi: 10.1521/pedi.2008.22.2.208.
Investigators from theoretically diverse backgrounds have long described two personality styles associated with depression. The affiliation style describes individuals with interpersonal concerns; the achievement style describes individuals who have concerns with personal failure. Although primarily related to risk for depression, there has also been recognition that extreme forms of these styles are related to personality disorders (PDs). The current study examines the relation between the DSM-IV PDs and the two personality styles, assessing the latter using two approaches: (a) dependency/self-criticism (Blatt, 1974) and (b) sociotropy/autonomy (Beck, 1983). Results show that whereas the achievement style is associated with most PDs (except for the histrionic and dependent PDs), the affiliation style is associated only with histrionic, dependent, and depressive PDs. Controlling for shared PD variance leaves only two associations, affiliation with dependent PD and achievement with narcissistic PD. Results are discussed in the context of current efforts to capture personality psychopathology within a comprehensive dimensional framework.
来自理论背景各异的研究人员长期以来一直描述了两种与抑郁症相关的人格风格。归属风格描述了关注人际关系的个体;成就风格描述了担心个人失败的个体。尽管这些风格主要与抑郁症风险相关,但人们也认识到这些风格的极端形式与人格障碍(PDs)有关。当前的研究考察了《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV)中的人格障碍与这两种人格风格之间的关系,使用两种方法评估后者:(a)依赖/自我批评(布拉特,1974年)和(b)社会依赖/自主(贝克,1983年)。结果表明,成就风格与大多数人格障碍相关(除表演型和依赖型人格障碍外),而归属风格仅与表演型、依赖型和抑郁型人格障碍相关。控制人格障碍的共同方差后,只剩下两种关联,即归属风格与依赖型人格障碍的关联以及成就风格与自恋型人格障碍的关联。在当前将人格精神病理学纳入综合维度框架的努力背景下对结果进行了讨论。