Pappas Dennis G
Pappas Ear Clinic, 2937 7th Avenue South, Birmingham, AL 35233, USA.
Laryngoscope. 2003 Oct;113(10):1658-71. doi: 10.1097/00005537-200310000-00005.
To demonstrate clinical evidence that vestibular symptomatology can occur in relation to autonomic dysfunction. Characterization of clinical findings and treatment response would then allow autonomic related vertigo to be differentiated from other vertiginous conditions that present in a like manner.
This was a retrospective review of 113 patients that described symptoms consistent with spontaneous, rotational vertigo and autonomic dysfunction.
Vestibular, otologic, and autonomic symptoms are presented along with the results of audiologic, orthostatic, and autonomic testing. Medical management included fluid loading, dietary changes, exercise, and patient education. Treatment results were analyzed according to the effectiveness in control of vestibular and otologic symptoms. Results were compared with a control group that demonstrated a similar vestibular and otologic presentation without autonomic symptomatology.
All patients described spontaneous, rotational vertigo, with complete or substantial vertigo control obtained in 93 (85%) of 110 patients. Postural vertigo and distinct lightheadedness were also documented in 53% and 97% of cases, respectively. Vertigo failed to improve or worsened with prior treatment of low sodium diet or diuretic in 53 (91%) of 58 cases. Vertigo improvement was subsequently achieved in 48 (86%) of 56 cases with an autonomic treatment regimen. Long-term vertigo control was obtained in 56 (88%) of 64 patients followed for at least 18 months. Tinnitus was reported in 97 (86%) patients, aural fullness in 93 (82%) patients, and subjective hearing loss (HL) in 46 (41%) of 111 cases. Bilateral tinnitus and aural fullness occurred in 65% and 63%, respectively. Tinnitus improved with treatment in 56 (67%) of 84 patients, whereas aural fullness improved in 59 (74%) of 80 patients. Autonomic symptoms included palpitations in 103 (91%) patients, chronic fatigue in 102 (90%) patients, cold extremities in 91 (81%) patients, and previous fainting in 72 (64%) patients. A history of mitral valve prolapse was documented in 51 (45%) of cases and demonstrated with echocardiogram in 68 (93%) of the 73 patients tested. Audiologic testing was normal in 104 (95%) of 109 patients, and electrocochleography was abnormal in 42 (40%) of 105 patients. Orthostatic blood pressure and heart rate testing met the criteria for orthostatic hypotension in 16 (15%) of 104 patients. Autonomic testing was obtained in 34 cases, with orthostatic intolerance demonstrated in 33 (97%) patients and orthostatic hypotension demonstrated in 13 (38%) patients. Overall, orthostatic hypotension was documented through combined testing results in 23 (21%) of 107 patients. Vertigo was reproduced during autonomic testing in 17 (77%) of 22 patients, and otologic symptoms were reproduce in 9 (47%) of 19 patients. Comparison of the study population with a control group without autonomic symptoms revealed statistically significant differences in orthostatic testing and treatment results. There was no statistical difference noted in findings between patients of this study that demonstrated or failed to demonstrate orthostatic hypotension.
There is a subgroup of patients with spontaneous vertigo who also demonstrate symptoms and findings consistent with poor autonomic regulation. These patients report vertigo improvement with a treatment strategy that aims to improve autonomic dysfunction through expansion of effective circulating volume. Clinical findings and treatment results of this study suggest an underlying autonomic influence in the production of vertigo and otologic symptoms.
证明前庭症状可能与自主神经功能障碍有关的临床证据。对临床发现和治疗反应进行特征描述,将有助于区分与自主神经相关的眩晕和其他以类似方式出现的眩晕病症。
这是一项对113例患者的回顾性研究,这些患者描述了与自发性旋转性眩晕和自主神经功能障碍相符的症状。
呈现前庭、耳科和自主神经症状,以及听力、直立位和自主神经测试结果。医学管理包括补液、饮食改变、运动和患者教育。根据控制前庭和耳科症状的有效性分析治疗结果。将结果与一个具有相似前庭和耳科表现但无自主神经症状的对照组进行比较。
所有患者均描述有自发性旋转性眩晕,110例患者中有93例(85%)的眩晕得到完全或显著控制。分别有53%和97%的病例记录有姿势性眩晕和明显的头晕。58例患者中有53例(91%)在先前采用低钠饮食或利尿剂治疗时眩晕未改善或加重。随后,56例患者中有48例(86%)采用自主神经治疗方案后眩晕得到改善。64例至少随访18个月的患者中有56例(88%)实现了长期眩晕控制。111例患者中有97例(86%)报告有耳鸣,93例(82%)有耳闷胀感,46例(41%)有主观听力损失。双侧耳鸣和耳闷胀感分别发生在65%和63%的患者中。84例患者中有56例(67%)耳鸣经治疗后改善,80例患者中有59例(74%)耳闷胀感改善。自主神经症状包括103例(91%)患者有心悸,102例(90%)患者有慢性疲劳,91例(81%)患者有四肢发冷,72例(64%)患者有既往晕厥史。51例(45%)病例记录有二尖瓣脱垂病史,73例接受超声心动图检查的患者中有68例(93%)证实有二尖瓣脱垂。109例患者中有104例(95%)听力测试正常,105例患者中有42例(40%)耳蜗电图异常。104例患者中有16例(15%)直立位血压和心率测试符合直立性低血压标准。34例患者进行了自主神经测试,33例(97%)患者有直立不耐受,13例(38%)患者有直立性低血压。总体而言,107例患者中有23例(21%)通过综合测试结果记录有直立性低血压。22例患者中有17例(77%)在自主神经测试期间再现眩晕,19例患者中有9例(47%)再现耳科症状。将研究人群与无自主神经症状的对照组进行比较,发现直立位测试和治疗结果存在统计学显著差异。本研究中表现出或未表现出直立性低血压的患者之间在检查结果上未发现统计学差异。
有一组自发性眩晕患者也表现出与自主神经调节不良相符的症状和体征。这些患者报告称,通过旨在通过增加有效循环血容量来改善自主神经功能障碍的治疗策略,眩晕症状得到改善。本研究的临床发现和治疗结果表明,自主神经在眩晕和耳科症状的产生中存在潜在影响。