Chinnaiyan Prakash, Tomée Wolfgang, Patel Rakesh, Chappell Rick, Ritter Mark
Department of Human Oncology K4/B100, University of Wisconsin Medical School, 600 Highland Avenue, Madison, WI 53792, USA.
Technol Cancer Res Treat. 2003 Oct;2(5):455-8. doi: 10.1177/153303460300200511.
Daily transabdominal ultrasound-directed localization has proven valuable in correcting for setup error and organ motion in the treatment of prostate cancer with three-dimensional conformal radiation therapy (3DCRT). The present study sought to determine whether this transabdominal ultrasound technology could also be reliably applied in the post-operative adjuvant or salvage setting to improve the reproducibility of coverage of the intended volumes and to enhance conformal avoidance of adjacent normal structures. Sixteen consecutive patients who received external beam radiotherapy underwent daily localization using an optically guided 3D-ultrasound target localization system (SonArray, Zmed, Inc., Ashland, MA). Six of the above patients were treated in a post-prostatectomy setting, either adjuvantly or for salvage, while the remaining 10 with intact prostates were treated definitively. Because the bladder neck generally approximates the postoperative prostatic fossa, it was used during ultrasound localization as the primary reference structure for the post-prostatectomy patients. For patients treated definitively, the prostate was the primary reference structure. Daily shifts were recorded and port films were taken weekly immediately after ultrasound-based repositioning. By comparing port films taken after ultrasound localization, which evaluates for both set-up error and internal shift, with the original digitally reconstructed radiographs (DRRs), which represents a zero clinical set-up error situation, the degree of variability in organ position was determined. The average absolute, ultrasound-based shifts from the clinical set-up position in the anterior/posterior, lateral, and cranial/caudal directions for the post-prostatectomy patients were 5 +/- 4 mm SD, 3 +/- 3 mm SD, and 3 +/- 4 mm SD over the entire course of treatment, respectively. The average vector length shift was 8 +/- 4 mm SD. For patients treated with an intact prostate, the analogous average absolute shifts in the anterior/posterior, lateral, and cranial/caudal directions were 4 +/- 3 mm SD, 4 +/- 3 mm SD, and 4 +/- 3 mm SD over the entire course of treatment. The average vector length shift was 7 +/- 4 mm SD. Vector length shifts representing interfraction internal motion were estimated by comparing post-ultrasound port films with DRRs. These were 5 +/- 3 mm SD and 4 +/- 4mm SD for post-prostatectomy and intact prostate patients, respectively. These ultrasound-based displacements were not statistically different in patients with an intact prostate versus patients post-prostatectomy (p > 0.1). In conclusion, daily transabdominal 3D-ultrasound localization proved to be a clinically feasible method of correcting for set-up and internal motion displacements. The bladder neck, which serves as an adequate localization reference structure for the prostatic fossa, could be readily ultrasound imaged and repositioned as necessary. Daily internal motion errors that would have occurred if only pre-treatment port films were used were similar in magnitude to those observed for the patients with intact prostates and were of sufficient magnitude to support the use of daily pre-treatment ultrasound localization in the post-prostatectomy setting.
在三维适形放射治疗(3DCRT)前列腺癌的过程中,每日经腹超声引导定位已被证明在纠正摆位误差和器官运动方面具有重要价值。本研究旨在确定这种经腹超声技术是否也能可靠地应用于术后辅助或挽救性治疗中,以提高靶区覆盖的可重复性,并增强对相邻正常结构的适形避让。16例接受外照射放疗的连续患者使用光学引导的三维超声靶区定位系统(SonArray,Zmed公司,马萨诸塞州阿什兰)进行每日定位。上述患者中有6例是在前列腺切除术后进行辅助或挽救性治疗,其余10例前列腺完整的患者接受根治性治疗。由于膀胱颈通常靠近术后前列腺窝,因此在超声定位时,它被用作前列腺切除术后患者的主要参考结构。对于接受根治性治疗的患者,前列腺是主要参考结构。记录每日的位移,并在基于超声重新定位后立即每周拍摄一次射野片。通过将评估摆位误差和内部位移的超声定位后拍摄的射野片与代表零临床摆位误差情况的原始数字重建影像(DRR)进行比较,确定器官位置的变异程度。前列腺切除术后患者在整个治疗过程中,基于超声的从临床摆位位置在前/后、侧方和头/尾方向的平均绝对位移分别为5±4mm标准差、3±3mm标准差和3±4mm标准差。平均矢量长度位移为8±4mm标准差。对于前列腺完整的患者,在整个治疗过程中,类似的在前/后、侧方和头/尾方向的平均绝对位移分别为4±3mm标准差、4±3mm标准差和4±3mm标准差。平均矢量长度位移为7±4mm标准差。通过比较超声定位后的射野片与DRR来估计代表分次间内部运动的矢量长度位移。前列腺切除术后患者和前列腺完整患者的这些位移分别为5±3mm标准差和4±4mm标准差。前列腺完整患者与前列腺切除术后患者的这些基于超声的位移在统计学上无差异(p>0.1)。总之,每日经腹三维超声定位被证明是一种纠正摆位和内部运动位移的临床可行方法。膀胱颈作为前列腺窝的合适定位参考结构,可以很容易地通过超声成像并根据需要重新定位。如果仅使用治疗前射野片,将会出现的每日内部运动误差在大小上与前列腺完整患者观察到的误差相似,并且其大小足以支持在前列腺切除术后的治疗中使用每日治疗前超声定位。