Smith L, Mason C
Shiftwork Research Group, School of Psychology, University of Leeds, UK.
J Hum Ergol (Tokyo). 2001 Dec;30(1-2):307-13.
The objective of this study was to examine age related effects of shiftwork albeit difficult to tease apart the natural effects of aging, and lifestyle or behaviour, or job done, over time and the shifts a person works. This is an issue of concern because the numbers of shiftworkers over 45 are increasing. Participants were 306 police officers who had worked a new rota for approximately 6 months. Three age groups were compared (1 = 20-32.9, 2 = 33-39.9, 3 = 40+) using a range of shiftwork-related measures and multivariate analysis of covariance (controlling for shiftwork experience and other individual differences). Younger officers tended to report significantly better attitudes towards their shiftwork, better adjustment to night-bound shifts, greater job satisfaction and organisational commitment, lower fatigue and longer sleep durations. Older shiftworkers reported significantly higher morningness and lower sleep need than the younger officers. This concurred with existing research that implicates such variables in the mechanism(s) involved in age-related tolerance to shiftwork. It was also evident that the older group tended to resort to greater caffeine intake on all shifts. The findings offer tentative support for the position that age can be linked to depleted shiftwork tolerance but the issue of establishing the relative impacts of aging, lifestyle, behaviour, work type and the rota worked remains to be a challenge.
本研究的目的是考察轮班工作与年龄相关的影响,尽管很难区分随着时间推移衰老、生活方式或行为、所从事工作以及个人所上轮班的自然影响。这是一个值得关注的问题,因为45岁以上的轮班工作者人数正在增加。研究参与者为306名警察,他们采用新的轮班表工作了约6个月。使用一系列与轮班工作相关的测量方法和协方差多元分析(控制轮班工作经验和其他个体差异),对三个年龄组(1组 = 20 - 32.9岁,2组 = 33 - 39.9岁,3组 = 40岁以上)进行了比较。年轻警察往往对轮班工作的态度明显更好,对夜班的适应性更强,工作满意度和组织承诺更高,疲劳程度更低,睡眠时间更长。年长的轮班工作者报告的晨型倾向明显高于年轻警察,睡眠需求则低于年轻警察。这与现有研究一致,这些研究表明这些变量参与了与年龄相关的轮班工作耐受性机制。同样明显的是,年长组在所有班次上往往摄入更多咖啡因。这些发现为年龄与轮班工作耐受性下降有关这一观点提供了初步支持,但确定衰老、生活方式、行为、工作类型和所上轮班表的相对影响问题仍然是一个挑战。