Johns D A, Ferland R, Dunn R
Texas Institute for Clinical Research, Fort Worth, Texas 76180, USA.
J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc. 2003 Aug;10(3):334-8. doi: 10.1016/s1074-3804(05)60257-5.
To assess the safety and effectiveness of SprayGel as a barrier to reduce the frequency of adhesion formation and reformation after ovarian surgery, and to determine the feasibility of the study design for a larger, multicenter pivotal trial.
Prospective, randomized, internally controlled trial (Canadian Task Force classification I).
Two metropolitan, academic-affiliated, nonprofit hospitals.
Fourteen women.
Bilateral adnexal surgery.
On completion of surgery, one adnexa was randomized to receive optimal surgical treatment plus application of the adhesion barrier, and the contralateral one to receive optimal surgical treatment alone. Patients returned in 3 to 16 weeks for second-look laparoscopy. All initial and second-look procedures were videotaped and reviewed by a blinded surgeon reviewer, and assessed for frequency, extent, and severity of adhesions. The frequency and extent of adhesion formation at second-look laparoscopy were statistically reduced on treatment sides compared with control sides (71% reduction in frequency, p = 0.0488; 69% reduction in extent, p = 0.0494). Adhesion severity score was reduced by 43% on the treatment side. SprayGel was associated with no adverse effects and was applied successfully in all patients.
This material shows great promise in preventing postoperative adhesion formation in a population of patients greatly in need of such an adjunct. These findings warrant a larger, pivotal, multicenter study to evaluate SprayGel further.
评估喷雾凝胶作为一种屏障在降低卵巢手术后粘连形成和再形成频率方面的安全性和有效性,并确定该研究设计用于更大规模多中心关键试验的可行性。
前瞻性、随机、自身对照试验(加拿大工作组分类I级)。
两家大都市的、与学术机构相关的非营利性医院。
14名女性。
双侧附件手术。
手术结束时,一侧附件随机接受最佳手术治疗并应用粘连屏障,对侧附件仅接受最佳手术治疗。患者在3至16周后返回进行二次腹腔镜检查。所有初次和二次手术过程均进行录像,并由一位不知情的外科医生审阅,评估粘连的频率、范围和严重程度。与对照侧相比,二次腹腔镜检查时治疗侧粘连形成的频率和范围在统计学上有所降低(频率降低71%,p = 0.0488;范围降低69%,p = 0.0494)。治疗侧粘连严重程度评分降低了43%。喷雾凝胶未出现不良反应,并在所有患者中成功应用。
这种材料在急需此类辅助手段的患者群体中预防术后粘连形成方面显示出巨大潜力。这些发现值得开展一项更大规模的关键多中心研究以进一步评估喷雾凝胶。