Heynick Louis N, Merritt James H
Consultant, Palo Alto, California 94303, USA.
Bioelectromagnetics. 2003;Suppl 6:S174-86. doi: 10.1002/bem.10127.
Experimental studies that sought teratologic effects or developmental abnormalities from exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic fields (RFEMF) in the range 3 kHz-300 GHz are critically reviewed for their possible consequences on human health. Those studies were conducted on beetles, birds, rodents, and nonhuman primates. Collectively, those experimental studies indicate that teratologic effects can occur only from exposure levels that cause biologically detrimental increases in body temperature. No reliable experimental evidence was found for nonthermal teratologic effects; rodents, mouse fetuses, and perinatal mice are more susceptible to such effects than rats. The primary confirmed effect in rats at high RFEMF levels was initial weight deficits in fetuses and neonates that decreased with infant growth. More generally from findings with pregnant mammals, exposures at RFEMF levels far higher than those permitted under the IEEE human exposure guidelines are necessary to reach or exceed cited experimental thresholds for maternal temperature increases. Some results indicated that the levels necessary to cause such effects in pregnant mammals could exceed those lethal to the dams. In a behavioral study of squirrel monkeys, no effects were observed on usual dam-offspring interactions or EEGs, but unexpected deaths of a number of offspring had occurred. However, this finding was not confirmed in a study solely on infant death using a larger number of subjects for greater statistical validity. Also reviewed were epidemiologic studies of various human populations considered to have been chronically exposed to environmental levels of RFEMF. Early studies on the incidence of congenital anomalies yielded no credible evidence that chronic exposure of pregnant women or of fathers exposed to RFEMF from nearby sources at levels below those guidelines would cause any anomalies in their offspring. The findings of studies on pregnancy outcomes of female physiotherapists occupationally exposed while treating patients with RFEMF were mixed, but taken collectively, the findings were negative.
对旨在研究暴露于3kHz - 300GHz范围内的射频电磁场(RFEMF)所产生的致畸作用或发育异常的实验研究进行了批判性审查,以探讨其对人类健康可能产生的后果。这些研究对象包括甲虫、鸟类、啮齿动物和非人类灵长类动物。总体而言,这些实验研究表明,只有在暴露水平导致体温出现对生物有害的升高时,才会产生致畸作用。未发现非热致畸作用的可靠实验证据;啮齿动物、小鼠胎儿和围产期小鼠比大鼠更容易受到此类影响。在高RFEMF水平下,大鼠的主要确认效应是胎儿和新生儿最初体重不足,且随着婴儿成长而减少。更普遍地从怀孕哺乳动物的研究结果来看,要达到或超过所引用的母体体温升高实验阈值,需要暴露于远高于IEEE人类暴露指南所允许水平的RFEMF。一些结果表明,在怀孕哺乳动物中引起此类效应所需的水平可能超过对母体致命的水平。在一项对松鼠猴的行为研究中,未观察到对母猴与后代之间通常的互动或脑电图有任何影响,但有一些后代意外死亡。然而,在一项仅针对婴儿死亡的研究中,使用了更多的受试者以提高统计有效性,该发现并未得到证实。还审查了对被认为长期暴露于环境水平RFEMF的各类人群的流行病学研究。早期关于先天性异常发生率的研究没有产生可信证据,表明孕妇或父亲在低于这些指南水平下暴露于附近来源的RFEMF会导致其后代出现任何异常。对职业暴露于RFEMF治疗患者的女性物理治疗师的妊娠结局研究结果不一,但总体而言,结果为阴性。