Zhang Xiao-Qing, Shirato Hiroki, Aoyama Hidefumi, Ushikoshi Satoshi, Nishioka Takeshi, Zhang Da-Zhen, Miyasaka Kazuo
Department of Radiotherapy, Shanghai Changhai Hospital, Shanghai, China.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2003 Dec 1;57(5):1392-9. doi: 10.1016/s0360-3016(03)00780-6.
A three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction method of arteriovenous malformation (AVM) nidus from digital subtraction angiography (DSA) in combination with CT and/or MRI was developed, and its usefulness was evaluated in this study.
The contour of the AVM nidus was delineated on two orthogonal projected DSA images. First, the volume and center of the AVM nidus were calculated in a classic DSA plan using three maximal lengths of the nidus in three perpendicular directions, assuming that the nidus had a prolate ellipsoid shape. Second, in the 3D-DSA plan, the contours of the AVM nidus on the two orthogonal projected DSA images were segmented to be compatible with the slice thickness of the CT image. Assuming that each segment of the nidus has an ellipsoid pillar shape, the volume and center of each segment were calculated. The volume and 3D shape of the nidus were calculated by 3D reconstruction in the 3D-DSA plan. Third, in the CT-DSA plan, the contour based on the segmented DSA was superimposed on the corresponding transaxial CT image slice by slice. The cylindrical shape of the nidus in the transaxial image was modified using the enhanced CT images in the CT-DSA plan. These three planning methods were compared using dose-volume statistics from real patients' data. Eighteen patients with intracranial AVMs in different brain locations who had been treated by radiosurgery were the subjects of this study. To examine the visibility (validity) of the nidus on the CT image, the "nidus" was delineated on an enhanced CT image without DSA superposition in the CT plan and compared with the CT-DSA plan.
The variance in the distance between coordinates determined by the CT plan and those determined by the classic DSA plan was significantly larger than the variance in the CT-DSA plan (p < 0.0001 for lateral, AP, and craniocaudal directions). The difference in the variance was not reduced by the addition of MRI (p < 0.0001 for each direction). The mean volume +/- SD of the nidus calculated was 5.9 +/- 8.0 cm(3) in the classic DSA plan, 4.0 +/- 5.6 cm(3) in the 3D-DSA plan, and 3.6 +/- 5.2 cm(3) in the CT-DSA plan. The 3D-DSA plan significantly reduced the mean nidus volume 31.8% +/- 12.7% from the classic DSA plan (p = 0.0054). The CT-DSA plan further significantly reduced the volume 9.8% +/- 8.8% from the 3D-DSA plan (p = 0.0021). The mean overlapping volume of the nidus between the CT plan and CT-DSA plan was 2.6 +/- 4.3 cm(3) (range 0.17-18.9), corresponding to 63.7% +/- 19.2% (range 11.4-85.3%) of the volume in the CT-DSA plan.
The superposition of the segmented DSA information on CT was shown to be an important tool to determine the precise shape of the nidus and is suggested to be useful to reduce partial occlusion of the AVM or radiation complications in radiosurgery.
开发一种将数字减影血管造影(DSA)与CT和/或MRI相结合的动静脉畸形(AVM)病灶三维(3D)重建方法,并在本研究中评估其有效性。
在两张相互正交投影的DSA图像上勾勒出AVM病灶的轮廓。首先,在经典DSA平面中,假设病灶呈长椭圆形,利用病灶在三个垂直方向上的三个最大长度计算AVM病灶的体积和中心。其次,在3D-DSA平面中,将两张相互正交投影的DSA图像上的AVM病灶轮廓进行分割,使其与CT图像的层厚相匹配。假设病灶的每一段呈椭圆柱状,计算每一段的体积和中心。通过在3D-DSA平面中进行三维重建来计算病灶的体积和三维形状。第三,在CT-DSA平面中,将基于分割后的DSA的轮廓逐片叠加到相应的横轴CT图像上。利用CT-DSA平面中的增强CT图像对横轴图像中病灶的圆柱形状进行修正。使用真实患者数据的剂量体积统计对这三种规划方法进行比较。本研究的对象为18例不同脑区颅内AVM且接受过放射外科治疗的患者。为了检查CT图像上病灶的可视性(有效性),在CT平面中未叠加DSA的增强CT图像上勾勒出“病灶”,并与CT-DSA平面进行比较。
CT平面确定的坐标与经典DSA平面确定的坐标之间的距离方差显著大于CT-DSA平面中的方差(横向、前后位和头脚方向p均<0.0001)。添加MRI后方差差异未减小(各方向p均<0.0001)。在经典DSA平面中计算的病灶平均体积±标准差为5.9±8.0 cm³,在3D-DSA平面中为4.0±5.6 cm³,在CT-DSA平面中为3.6±5.2 cm³。3D-DSA平面使病灶平均体积比经典DSA平面显著减少31.8%±12.7%(p = 0.0054)。CT-DSA平面使体积比3D-DSA平面进一步显著减少9.8%±8.8%(p = 0.0021)。CT平面与CT-DSA平面中病灶的平均重叠体积为2.6±4.3 cm³(范围0.17 - 18.9),相当于CT-DSA平面中体积的63.7%±19.2%(范围11.4 - 85.3%)。
将分割后的DSA信息叠加到CT上被证明是确定病灶精确形状的重要工具,并且建议其有助于减少放射外科中AVM的部分闭塞或放射并发症。