Snow Vincenza, Weiss Kevin B, LeFevre Michael, McNamara Robert, Bass Eric, Green Lee A, Michl Keith, Owens Douglas K, Susman Jeffrey, Allen Deborah I, Mottur-Pilson Christel
American College of Physicians, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19106, USA.
Ann Intern Med. 2003 Dec 16;139(12):1009-17. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-139-12-200312160-00011.
The Joint Panel of the American Academy of Family Physicians and the American College of Physicians, in collaboration with the Johns Hopkins Evidence-based Practice Center, systematically reviewed the available evidence on the management of newly detected atrial fibrillation and developed recommendations for adult patients with first-detected atrial fibrillation. The recommendations do not apply to patients with postoperative or post-myocardial infarction atrial fibrillation, patients with class IV heart failure, patients already taking antiarrhythmic drugs, or patients with valvular disease. The target physician audience is internists and family physicians dedicated to primary care. The recommendations are as follows: RECOMMENDATION 1: Rate control with chronic anticoagulation is the recommended strategy for the majority of patients with atrial fibrillation. Rhythm control has not been shown to be superior to rate control (with chronic anticoagulation) in reducing morbidity and mortality and may be inferior in some patient subgroups to rate control. Rhythm control is appropriate when based on other special considerations, such as patient symptoms, exercise tolerance, and patient preference. Grade: 2A. RECOMMENDATION 2: Patients with atrial fibrillation should receive chronic anticoagulation with adjusted-dose warfarin, unless they are at low risk of stroke or have a specific contraindication to the use of warfarin (thrombocytopenia, recent trauma or surgery, alcoholism). Grade: 1A. RECOMMENDATION 3: For patients with atrial fibrillation, the following drugs are recommended for their demonstrated efficacy in rate control during exercise and while at rest: atenolol, metoprolol, diltiazem, and verapamil (drugs listed alphabetically by class). Digoxin is only effective for rate control at rest and therefore should only be used as a second-line agent for rate control in atrial fibrillation. Grade: 1B. RECOMMENDATION 4: For those patients who elect to undergo acute cardioversion to achieve sinus rhythm in atrial fibrillation, both direct-current cardioversion (Grade: 1C+) and pharmacological conversion (Grade: 2A) are appropriate options. RECOMMENDATION 5: Both transesophageal echocardiography with short-term prior anticoagulation followed by early acute cardioversion (in the absence of intracardiac thrombus) with postcardioversion anticoagulation versus delayed cardioversion with pre- and postanticoagulation are appropriate management strategies for those patients who elect to undergo cardioversion. Grade: 2A. RECOMMENDATION 6: Most patients converted to sinus rhythm from atrial fibrillation should not be placed on rhythm maintenance therapy since the risks outweigh the benefits. In a selected group of patients whose quality of life is compromised by atrial fibrillation, the recommended pharmacologic agents for rhythm maintenance are amiodarone, disopyramide, propafenone, and sotalol (drugs listed in alphabetical order). The choice of agent predominantly depends on specific risk of side effects based on patient characteristics. Grade: 2A.
美国家庭医生学会和美国内科医师学会联合小组与约翰霍普金斯循证实践中心合作,系统回顾了新检测出的心房颤动管理方面的现有证据,并为首次检测出心房颤动的成年患者制定了建议。这些建议不适用于术后或心肌梗死后心房颤动患者、IV级心力衰竭患者、已服用抗心律失常药物的患者或瓣膜病患者。目标医生群体是致力于初级保健的内科医生和家庭医生。建议如下:
建议1:对于大多数心房颤动患者,推荐采用慢性抗凝的心率控制策略。在降低发病率和死亡率方面,节律控制并未显示优于心率控制(联合慢性抗凝),在某些患者亚组中可能不如心率控制。基于其他特殊考虑因素(如患者症状、运动耐量和患者偏好)时,节律控制是合适的。分级:2A。
建议2:心房颤动患者应接受调整剂量华法林的慢性抗凝治疗,除非他们发生卒中的风险较低或有使用华法林的特定禁忌证(血小板减少症、近期创伤或手术、酗酒)。分级:1A。
建议3:对于心房颤动患者,以下药物因其在运动和静息时心率控制方面已证实的疗效而被推荐:阿替洛尔、美托洛尔、地尔硫䓬和维拉帕米(按类别字母顺序列出药物)。地高辛仅对静息时的心率控制有效,因此仅应作为心房颤动心率控制的二线药物使用。分级:1B。
建议4:对于那些选择进行急性心脏复律以恢复心房颤动窦性心律的患者,直流电复律(分级:1C+)和药物复律(分级:2A)都是合适的选择。
建议5:对于那些选择进行心脏复律的患者,经食管超声心动图检查并在短期预先抗凝,随后在无心脏内血栓的情况下进行早期急性心脏复律并在复律后抗凝,与延迟复律并在复律前后抗凝都是合适的管理策略。分级:2A。
建议6:大多数从心房颤动转为窦性心律的患者不应接受节律维持治疗,因为风险大于获益。在一组因心房颤动而生活质量受损的特定患者中,推荐用于节律维持的药物有胺碘酮、丙吡胺、普罗帕酮和索他洛尔(按字母顺序列出药物)。药物的选择主要取决于基于患者特征的特定副作用风险。分级:2A。