Swahnberg I M Katarina, Wijma Barbro
Division of Women's Health, Department of Molecular and Clinical Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences, Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden.
Eur J Public Health. 2003 Dec;13(4):361-6. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/13.4.361.
In the literature about abuse, large variations in prevalence rates exist. Validated research instruments are scarce and are needed urgently. Our aim was to validate the 13 questions concerning the experiences of abuse among women in the NorVold Abuse Questionnaire against an interview and two validated questionnaires.
Data collection was in two parts. i) The NorVold Abuse Questionnaire was sent to a random sample of 2000 women in Ostergötland. ii) A subsample of 64 women was interviewed, and filled in the Conflict Tactic Scale, the Sexual Abuse Questionnaire, and the NorVold Abuse Questionnaire for a second time. The interview had open questions about abuse and was considered our gold standard.
The response rate was 61%. The abuse variables in The NorVold Abuse Questionnaire showed good test-retest reliability (84-95%). Specificity was 98% for all kinds of abuse except physical (85%). Sensitivity ranged from 75% (emotional) to 96% (physical). The likelihood ratio ranged from 38 to 43 for all kinds of abuse except physical (likelihood ratio 6). NorAQ performed better against the interview than against the Sexual Abuse Questionnaire and equally against the Conflict Tactic Scale. High lifetime prevalence rates of abuse were found: emotional 21.4%; physical 36.4%; sexual 16.9%; abuse in the health care 15.6%. Prevalence rates of abuse dropped considerably when a criterion of current suffering was added.
The abuse variables in NorAQ have good reliability and validity.
在关于虐待的文献中,患病率存在很大差异。经过验证的研究工具稀缺,急需此类工具。我们的目的是对照一次访谈以及两份经过验证的问卷,验证诺沃尔德虐待问卷中有关女性虐待经历的13个问题。
数据收集分两部分。i)将诺沃尔德虐待问卷发送给东约特兰省2000名女性的随机样本。ii)对64名女性的子样本进行访谈,并再次填写冲突策略量表、性虐待问卷和诺沃尔德虐待问卷。访谈包含关于虐待的开放式问题,被视为我们的金标准。
回复率为61%。诺沃尔德虐待问卷中的虐待变量显示出良好的重测信度(84 - 95%)。除身体虐待外(特异性为85%),各类虐待的特异性均为98%。敏感性范围从情感虐待的75%到身体虐待的96%。除身体虐待外(似然比为6),各类虐待的似然比范围为38至43。与访谈相比,诺沃尔德虐待问卷在针对性虐待问卷时表现更好,而与冲突策略量表表现相当。发现较高的终身虐待患病率:情感虐待21.4%;身体虐待36.4%;性虐待16.9%;医疗保健中的虐待15.6%。当加入当前痛苦的标准时,虐待患病率大幅下降。
诺沃尔德虐待问卷中的虐待变量具有良好的信度和效度。