Black Helen K, Rubinstein Robert L
Polisher Research Institute, Jenkintown, Pennsylvania, USA.
J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci. 2004 Jan;59(1):S17-24. doi: 10.1093/geronb/59.1.s17.
This qualitative research study explored the personal meaning of suffering to a group of 40 community-dwelling elders, stratified by gender and race.
We recruited 40 informants who were 70 years old or older from the Philadelphia, PA, area for extended qualitative interviews, which elicited their life story and experiences and philosophies about suffering. Cells contained 10 African American men and women and 10 European American men and women each (N = 40). Through analysis of data, we placed elders' experiences of suffering under three general themes: suffering as lack of control, suffering as loss, and the value of suffering.
Informants developed a unique definition, attribution, theory, and theodicy about suffering based on the particularity of the experience as well as how they "fit" suffering into their lives as a whole. Brief case studies illustrate how themes emerged in elders' stories of suffering.
On the basis of this research, it appears that, although they have some similarities, elders' experiences of suffering are unique and incomparable. Similarities concern informants' connection of suffering with finitude. The incomparability of suffering experiences relate to informants' unique personal histories, perceptions, and "cause" of suffering. Through the process of the interview, elders connect the suffering experience to the entirety of the life lived and the story of suffering to the life story.
本定性研究探讨了40名社区居住老年人对苦难的个人理解,这些老年人按性别和种族分层。
我们从宾夕法尼亚州费城地区招募了40名70岁及以上的受访者,进行深入的定性访谈,以了解他们的人生故事、经历以及对苦难的看法和理念。每组包含10名非裔美国男性和女性以及10名欧美裔男性和女性(N = 40)。通过数据分析,我们将老年人的苦难经历归纳为三个总体主题:作为缺乏控制的苦难、作为损失的苦难以及苦难的价值。
受访者基于经历的特殊性以及他们如何将苦难“融入”整个生活,形成了关于苦难的独特定义、归因、理论和神正论。简短的案例研究说明了这些主题是如何在老年人的苦难故事中呈现的。
基于这项研究,尽管老年人的苦难经历有一些相似之处,但似乎这些经历是独特且无可比拟的。相似之处在于受访者将苦难与有限性联系起来。苦难经历的无可比拟性与受访者独特的个人经历、认知以及苦难的“原因”有关。通过访谈过程,老年人将苦难经历与整个生活联系起来,并将苦难故事与人生故事联系起来。