Vincent Dale S, Berg Benjamin W, Hudson Donald A, Chitpatima Suwicha T
Department of Medicine, Tripler Army Medical Center, Honolulu, Hawaii 96859-5000, USA.
J Telemed Telecare. 2003;9 Suppl 2:S71-2. doi: 10.1258/135763303322596336.
International medical education sessions have been successfully conducted by videoconferencing using Internet2. The sessions were between two tertiary care medical centres, in Honolulu and Bangkok. However, video quality was lower than for similar sessions using ISDN and audience satisfaction was less. The main reasons for the lower quality were network congestion and bandwidth allocation by the videoconferencing equipment. Software to ensure quality of service is available, but is not easy to implement. There were also network security problems and the costs were high. Our international videoconferences averaged 40-50 hours per year, an activity level at which connection costs were lower for ISDN than for Internet2. It appears that Internet2 videoconferencing for medical education is best reserved for academic institutions that have other high-bandwidth network requirements.
利用第二代互联网通过视频会议成功举办了国际医学教育会议。会议在檀香山和曼谷的两个三级医疗中心之间举行。然而,视频质量低于使用综合业务数字网(ISDN)的类似会议,观众满意度也较低。质量较低的主要原因是网络拥塞和视频会议设备的带宽分配。有确保服务质量的软件,但不易实施。还存在网络安全问题,且成本高昂。我们的国际视频会议平均每年40 - 50小时,在这个活动水平上,综合业务数字网的连接成本低于第二代互联网。看来,用于医学教育的第二代互联网视频会议最好留给有其他高带宽网络需求的学术机构。