Prasad Ganesh, Dhillon Mandeep S, Khullar Madhu, Nagi Onkar N
Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India.
Acta Orthop Belg. 2003 Dec;69(6):546-51.
In a preliminary attempt to see if oxidative stress occurs after major fractures, we evaluated two groups of patients sustaining a single fracture (Group A) and multiple fractures (Group B), and compared them with healthy controls (Group C). Indirect evaluation using plasma was done, as serial samples directly from bone could not be taken in humans. We measured plasma levels of malonyldialdehyde (MDA), which depicts the lipid peroxide content, and the unstable nitric Acid (indirectly through measuring reactive nitrogen intermediates and citrulline), serially over a four-week period. The endogenous ferric reducing anti-oxidant power assay (FRAP) was also done. All these have been proven to be representative of oxidative stress in other situations. We noted significant changes in these values, peaking by the 2nd and 3rd weeks post fracture, and coming down by the 4th week. This implies that oxidative stress does occur after a fracture; the initial few days are eventless, probably because the fracture causes a local region of ischaemia. Oxidant levels rise by the 2nd and 3rd week, perhaps due to callus formation and angiogenesis, which results in reperfusion at the fracture site. Oxidative stress may also be proportional to the number of bones fractured, as Group B, with multiple fractures had more elevated values. The antioxidant levels also behave similarly to combat the detrimental effect. The pro and antioxidants values then gradually decline by the 4th week, probably because by then the bone starts to organize. A better understanding of these mechanisms may help in defining the role of oxidative stresses after fracture and perhaps better define the role of antioxidants in helping fracture healing.
为初步探究严重骨折后是否会发生氧化应激反应,我们评估了两组骨折患者,其中一组为单处骨折患者(A组),另一组为多处骨折患者(B组),并将他们与健康对照组(C组)进行比较。由于无法在人体上直接采集来自骨骼的系列样本,因此采用血浆进行间接评估。我们连续四周测量血浆中丙二醛(MDA)的水平(其可反映脂质过氧化物含量)以及不稳定硝酸(通过测量活性氮中间体和瓜氨酸间接得出)。同时还进行了内源性铁还原抗氧化能力分析(FRAP)。所有这些指标在其他情况下均已被证明可代表氧化应激反应。我们注意到这些数值有显著变化,在骨折后第2周和第3周达到峰值,到第4周时下降。这表明骨折后确实会发生氧化应激反应;最初几天没有变化,可能是因为骨折导致局部缺血。氧化水平在第2周和第3周升高,可能是由于骨痂形成和血管生成,导致骨折部位再灌注。氧化应激反应也可能与骨折的骨数量成正比,因为多处骨折的B组数值升高得更多。抗氧化剂水平的变化情况也类似,以对抗有害影响。然后,促氧化剂和抗氧化剂的值在第4周时逐渐下降,可能是因为此时骨骼开始愈合。更好地理解这些机制可能有助于明确骨折后氧化应激反应的作用,或许还能更好地确定抗氧化剂在促进骨折愈合中的作用。