Lee Wai Man, Wong Frances Kam Yuet, Mok Esther S B
School of Nursing, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong, China.
Nurse Educ Today. 2004 Feb;24(2):136-44. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2003.10.012.
Problem-based learning (PBL) has been widely adopted as a strategy by nurse educators all over the world. Many studies have been carried out to examine its process and outcomes. There are few studies discussing the relevance of PBL to students with different cultural background. This study reports the experiences of Chinese students in Hong Kong using PBL and explores if their experiences were compatible with the educational philosophy documented in traditional Chinese literature. The phenomenological approach was used in the treatment of data. The informants were students enrolled in the post-registration nursing degree programme at a university in Hong Kong during 1997-1998. A total of 94 journals were included in the analysis. Seven main themes emerged from the phenomenological analysis. They were the integration of knowing and doing, critical reflection and debate, individuality of learning, self-motivated learning, critical inquiry and independent thinking, timeliness of instruction and cooperative learning. This study provides evidence to show that PBL is an approach that is compatible with the Chinese way of learning. The result of this study shows that aspects of the modern PBL process harken back to an ancient Chinese learning philosophy that underpins Chinese learning today.
基于问题的学习(PBL)已被世界各地的护理教育工作者广泛采用为一种教学策略。已经开展了许多研究来考察其过程和结果。很少有研究探讨PBL与不同文化背景学生的相关性。本研究报告了香港中国学生使用PBL的经历,并探讨他们的经历是否与中国传统文献中记载的教育理念相符。采用现象学方法处理数据。研究对象是1997 - 1998年期间在香港一所大学攻读注册后护理学位课程的学生。分析共纳入94篇日志。现象学分析得出七个主要主题。它们是知行合一、批判性反思与辩论、学习的个性、自主学习、批判性探究与独立思考、教学的及时性以及合作学习。本研究提供证据表明PBL是一种与中国学习方式相符的教学方法。本研究结果表明,现代PBL过程的一些方面可追溯到一种古老的中国学习理念,这种理念支撑着当今的中国学习。