Lee M S, King C C, Jean J Y, Kao C L, Wang C C, Ho M S, Chen C J, Lee G C
Institute of Public Health, National Taiwan University (NTU), Taipei, Republic of China ROC.
Int J Epidemiol. 1992 Dec;21(6):1165-74. doi: 10.1093/ije/21.6.1165.
A seroepidemiological study was carried out to explore the risk factors of a measles outbreak that occurred among school children at a rural village (Li-Tse) in Taiwan. Among the 1166 participants, the percentage susceptible before the outbreak was 10.5% (122/1158) which was estimated as the sum of measles IgG-negative (29/1158) and IgM-positive (93/1166) individuals. Among 340 vaccinated children, 16 (4.7%) were measles IgM-positive and 10 (2.9%) were measles IgG-negative; therefore the vaccine failure rate was estimated to be 7.6% (26/340) and vaccine efficacy was 79.7% (95% confidence interval [CI] : 65.0-88.5). The most important risk factors for acquiring measles infection were the presence of other measles cases in the family (Odds Ratio [OR] = 32.5, P = 0.002) and the presence of more than two cases in a class (OR = 29.1, P = 0.003). The physician reporting rate was 6.1% (4/66), and the sensitivity of passive measles surveillance was only 4.3% (4/93) by active serosurvey. A concomitant rubella epidemic also amplified the inaccuracy of a passive reporting system based only on clinical diagnosis. Five children developed measles IgM but did not experience any symptoms, indicating that asymptomatic measles infection can occur. Our experience has highlighted three important areas for future measles elimination: (1) the need for serological evaluation of vaccinees, particularly those who were born during the introduction of mass immunization; (2) improvement in measles vaccine efficacy; and (3) further investigations on the role of asymptomatic transmission and susceptibles who remain after mass immunization.
开展了一项血清流行病学研究,以探究台湾一个乡村(立泽)在校儿童中发生麻疹暴发的风险因素。在1166名参与者中,暴发前的易感百分比为10.5%(122/1158),该百分比是通过将麻疹IgG阴性(29/1158)和IgM阳性(93/1166)个体相加估算得出的。在340名接种过疫苗的儿童中,16名(4.7%)麻疹IgM呈阳性,10名(2.9%)麻疹IgG呈阴性;因此,疫苗失败率估计为7.6%(26/340),疫苗效力为79.7%(95%置信区间[CI]:65.0 - 88.5)。感染麻疹的最重要风险因素是家庭中存在其他麻疹病例(优势比[OR]=32.5,P = 0.002)以及班级中存在两例以上病例(OR = 29.1,P = 0.003)。医生报告率为6.1%(4/66),通过主动血清学调查,被动麻疹监测的敏感性仅为4.3%(4/93)。同时发生的风疹疫情也加剧了仅基于临床诊断的被动报告系统的不准确性。5名儿童麻疹IgM呈阳性,但未出现任何症状,这表明可能发生无症状麻疹感染。我们的经验突出了未来消除麻疹的三个重要方面:(1)需要对接种疫苗者进行血清学评估,尤其是那些在大规模免疫接种引入期间出生的人;(2)提高麻疹疫苗效力;(3)进一步调查无症状传播的作用以及大规模免疫接种后仍存在的易感者情况。