Scully Paul J, Owens John M, Kinsella Anthony, Waddington John L
Stanley Research Unit, St. Davnet's Hospital, Monaghan, Ireland.
Schizophr Res. 2004 Apr 1;67(2-3):143-55. doi: 10.1016/S0920-9964(03)00194-4.
While a controversy has endured as to whether schizophrenia evidences the geographical variations in rate that characterise essentially all medical conditions, even less is known of such fundamental aspects of the epidemiology of schizoaffective and bipolar disorder. Within an ethnically and socioeconomically homogeneous region of rural Ireland, population 29,542, several methodological refinements were adopted to seek an epidemiologically complete population of 'all' cases of these disorders, with each potential case interviewed and diagnosed. Prevalence and morbid risk were calculated over the region as a whole and for each of the 39 constituent District Electoral Divisions [DEDs], by place at birth and by place at onset. Using multiple sources of information, 115 cases of schizophrenia, 33 of schizoaffective disorder and 77 of bipolar disorder were identified. Unremarkable overall prevalence and morbid risk values obscured marked variation between District Electoral Divisions for schizophrenia. No such variation was observed for bipolar disorder. These data indicate, using improved methodology, that what is often interpreted as an invariant overall rate of schizophrenia across countries and cultures may not apply to spatial microstructure; macroscopic rates can obscure small area variations when ethnic and socioeconomic diversity are minimised and effects of urbanicity are absent. Under these conditions, small area variations in bipolar disorder may be limited.
关于精神分裂症是否存在几乎所有医学病症都具有的发病率地理差异一直存在争议,而对于分裂情感性障碍和双相情感障碍流行病学的这些基本方面,人们了解得更少。在爱尔兰农村一个种族和社会经济同质化的地区(人口29542),采用了几种方法改进措施来寻找这些疾病“所有”病例的完整流行病学人群,对每个潜在病例进行访谈和诊断。计算了整个地区以及39个组成区选举分区(DEDs)中每个分区按出生地点和发病地点划分的患病率和患病风险。通过多种信息来源,确定了115例精神分裂症病例、33例分裂情感性障碍病例和77例双相情感障碍病例。总体患病率和患病风险值并无异常,但精神分裂症在区选举分区之间存在明显差异。双相情感障碍未观察到此类差异。这些数据表明,采用改进方法后,通常被解释为各国和各文化中精神分裂症总体发病率不变的情况可能不适用于空间微观结构;当种族和社会经济多样性最小化且不存在城市化影响时,宏观发病率可能掩盖小区域差异。在这些条件下,双相情感障碍的小区域差异可能有限。