Mahan Clare M, Kang Han K, Dalager Nancy A, Heller Jack M
Veterans Health Administration, Department of Veterans Affairs, Washington, DC, USA.
Ann Epidemiol. 2004 Feb;14(2):81-8. doi: 10.1016/S1047-2797(03)00124-8.
To evaluate the health status of Gulf War veterans who reported receipt of anthrax vaccination and a small group of Gulf War veterans for whom documentation of anthrax vaccination exists.
Among the 11,441 Gulf War veterans who completed a health survey, 4601 reported receiving the anthrax vaccine during the war; 2979 veterans reported not receiving it; 3861 were uncertain. Also, 352 of these respondents were documented by the Department of Defense as having received anthrax vaccination. We compared the medical history of these groups of veterans using multivariate analyses. Finally, we analyzed perception of exposure and its relation to reporting bias.
There were statistically significant differences in prevalence for almost all outcomes studied between those who reported having received anthrax vaccination and those who did not so report. However, when we compared the veterans for whom vaccination records exist to the group who self-reported that they had not received the vaccine, the significant differences in prevalence for almost all of the outcomes disappeared.
The extent of a reporting bias should be carefully considered when one evaluates the health consequences of anthrax vaccination based on self-reported data.
评估报告接种过炭疽疫苗的海湾战争退伍军人以及一小部分有炭疽疫苗接种记录的海湾战争退伍军人的健康状况。
在完成健康调查的11441名海湾战争退伍军人中,4601人报告在战争期间接种了炭疽疫苗;2979名退伍军人报告未接种;3861人不确定。此外,这些受访者中有352人被国防部记录为接种过炭疽疫苗。我们使用多变量分析比较了这些退伍军人组的病史。最后,我们分析了暴露感知及其与报告偏倚的关系。
报告接种过炭疽疫苗的人与未报告接种的人相比,几乎所有研究结果的患病率在统计学上都有显著差异。然而,当我们将有疫苗接种记录的退伍军人与自我报告未接种疫苗的组进行比较时,几乎所有结果的患病率显著差异都消失了。
在基于自我报告数据评估炭疽疫苗接种的健康后果时,应仔细考虑报告偏倚的程度。