Ramos-Casals Manuel, Brito-Zerón Pilar, García-Carrasco Mario, Font Josep
From Department of Autoimmune Diseases (MR-C, PB-Z, MG-C, JF),Institut d' Investigacions Biomèdiques August Pi i Sunyer (IDIBAPS), University of Barcelona, Hospital Clínic, Barcelona, Spain; and Rheumatology Department of School of Medicine (MG-C), University of Puebla, Puebla, Mexico.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2004 Mar;83(2):85-95. doi: 10.1097/01.md.0000121237.98962.1e.
We present 5 new cases of coexisting sarcoidosis and Sjögren syndrome (SS) and review the literature for additional cases in order to analyze the clinical, immunologic, and histologic characteristics that may help physicians differentiate the mimicry of SS by sarcoidosis from a true coexistence of both autoimmune diseases. We considered the coexistence of sarcoidosis with SS to be when patients presented specific histologic patterns of both diseases, simultaneously or at different times.Fifty-nine patients were included in the analysis (54 identified in the literature search plus our 5 unpublished cases): 49 (83%) patients were female and 10 (17%) were male, with a mean age at diagnosis of 50 years. According to the histopathologic examination of the exocrine glands performed in 53 cases, we defined coexistence of sarcoidosis and SS in 28 cases, while in the remaining 25 patients, sarcoidosis mimicked SS. Clues to identifying when sarcoidosis coexists with SS were a higher prevalence of systemic manifestations (arthritis and uveitis) and positive immunologic parameters (antinuclear antibodies, rheumatoid factor, and anti-Ro/SS-A), as well as the existence of a focal sialadenitis (Chisholm-Mason score grades III-IV, with a CD4+ lymphocytic infiltration) in the salivary gland biopsy. In patients first diagnosed with primary SS, the appearance of some clinical features such as hilar adenopathies, uveitis, or hypercalcemia leads to the diagnosis of coexisting sarcoidosis. A careful application of the new American-European consensus criteria had a sensitivity of 93% and a specificity of 92% in identifying when SS coexists with sarcoidosis.In conclusion, the association of sarcoidosis with SS leads to a true coexistence of both diseases in more than half the patients described in the literature, while in the remaining patients, sarcoidosis mimics SS. In light of these results, sarcoidosis should not be considered as an exclusion criterion for the diagnosis of SS, and in patients with a suspected overlap of the two diseases, application of the new American-European consensus criteria for diagnosis of SS should be mandatory.
我们报告了5例结节病与干燥综合征(SS)并存的新病例,并查阅文献以寻找更多病例,以便分析可能有助于医生区分结节病对SS的模仿与这两种自身免疫性疾病真正并存的临床、免疫和组织学特征。我们认为,当患者同时或在不同时间呈现出两种疾病的特定组织学模式时,即为结节病与SS并存。
59例患者纳入分析(54例通过文献检索确定,加上我们未发表的5例病例):49例(83%)为女性,10例(17%)为男性,诊断时的平均年龄为50岁。根据53例患者外分泌腺的组织病理学检查,我们确定28例为结节病与SS并存,而其余25例患者中,结节病模仿了SS。结节病与SS并存的识别线索包括全身表现(关节炎和葡萄膜炎)及免疫参数阳性(抗核抗体、类风湿因子和抗Ro/SS-A)的患病率较高,以及唾液腺活检中存在局灶性涎腺炎(Chisholm-Mason评分III-IV级,伴有CD4+淋巴细胞浸润)。在最初诊断为原发性SS的患者中,出现一些临床特征如肺门淋巴结肿大、葡萄膜炎或高钙血症会导致并存结节病的诊断。新的欧美共识标准在识别SS与结节病并存时,敏感性为93%,特异性为92%。
总之,在文献报道的患者中,超过半数结节病与SS的关联导致了两种疾病的真正并存,而其余患者中,结节病模仿了SS。鉴于这些结果,结节病不应被视为SS诊断的排除标准,对于怀疑两种疾病重叠的患者,应强制应用新的欧美SS诊断共识标准。