Ou Chau-Su, Huang U-Chen, Tsuang Mary, Rowbotham Ron
Department of Research & Development, Northwest Hospital, Seattle, WA 98133, USA.
J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 2004 Feb;14(1):17-21. doi: 10.1089/109264204322862306.
To describe a methodology for laparoscopic repair of vesicovaginal fistula (VVF), and to provide a comparison of results between a series of laparoscopic repairs, a series of transabdominal open repairs (TAORs), a series of transvaginal repairs (TVRs), and cases successfully managed without surgery.
A total of 16 patients were diagnosed with post-hysterectomy VVF. All patients were first managed conservatively with continuous drainage via a Foley catheter until dry. In 2 of the 16 cases (12.5%) the fistulae healed spontaneously with conservative management. After 4-12 weeks, the remaining 14 patients underwent surgical repair of their fistulas; 2 (14%) by laparoscopy, 6 (43%) by TAOR, and 6 (43%) by TVR.
Fistula repair was successful in both laparoscopy cases, all 6 TAOR cases, and 5 of 6 TVR cases (86%). The failed transvaginal repair was repeated, with a successful outcome. Length of hospital stay was 7-10 days (mean, 8.3 days) for the open cases, 3-5 days (mean, 4.1 days) for the transvaginal cases, and 2-12 days for the laparoscopic cases. One patient who underwent laparoscopic repair had a 12-day hospital stay due to extended vaginal drainage lasting 3 weeks, which then resolved. Three of the 6 patients who underwent TAOR (50%) experienced postoperative complications, including 2 cases of ileus and 1 case of fever. One of 6 patients who underwent TVR (16%) experienced recurrent urinary tract infection.
These data suggest that laparoscopic VVF repair is feasible and may result in lower morbidity, shorter hospital stay, and quicker recovery than the abdominal or transvaginal approaches. Additional controlled studies are warranted. The minimally invasive approach of laparoscopy may be a more attractive option for patients who experience VVF following hysterectomy.
描述一种腹腔镜修复膀胱阴道瘘(VVF)的方法,并比较一系列腹腔镜修复、一系列经腹开放修复(TAOR)、一系列经阴道修复(TVR)以及非手术成功治疗病例之间的结果。
共有16例患者被诊断为子宫切除术后膀胱阴道瘘。所有患者首先通过Foley导管持续引流进行保守治疗,直至瘘口干燥。16例患者中有2例(12.5%)经保守治疗后瘘口自愈。4 - 12周后,其余14例患者接受了瘘口的手术修复;2例(14%)采用腹腔镜修复,6例(43%)采用经腹开放修复,6例(43%)采用经阴道修复。
腹腔镜修复的2例、所有6例经腹开放修复以及6例经阴道修复中的5例(86%)瘘口修复成功。经阴道修复失败的病例进行了再次修复,结果成功。开放手术病例的住院时间为7 - 10天(平均8.3天),经阴道手术病例为3 - 5天(平均4.1天),腹腔镜手术病例为2 - 12天。1例接受腹腔镜修复的患者因持续3周的阴道延长引流导致住院12天,之后引流情况得到缓解。6例经腹开放修复患者中有3例(50%)出现术后并发症,包括2例肠梗阻和1例发热。6例经阴道修复患者中有1例(16%)出现复发性尿路感染。
这些数据表明,腹腔镜膀胱阴道瘘修复是可行的,与经腹或经阴道手术相比可能导致更低的发病率、更短的住院时间和更快的恢复。需要进行更多对照研究。对于子宫切除术后发生膀胱阴道瘘的患者,腹腔镜这种微创方法可能是更具吸引力的选择。