Libeton Marije, Dixon John B, Laurie Cheryl, O'Brien Paul E
Monash University Department of Surgery, Alfred Hospital, Melbourne 3181, Victoria, Australia.
Obes Surg. 2004 Mar;14(3):392-8. doi: 10.1381/096089204322917936.
Motivation for seeking obesity surgery has not been studied. The authors explored the patient's motivation for selecting surgery and examined for a relationship between primary motivating factors and weight outcomes.
208 (177F: 31M) unselected participants followed at least 1 year after Lap-Band placement completed a short questionnaire. 6 statements were scored 1-6 from the most important through to the least important. Statements included appearance, embarrassment, medical conditions, health concerns, physical fitness and physical limitation. Any additional factors were also sought.
Mean age, weight and BMI before surgery were 41+/-10 years, 129+/-16 kg and 46+/-8 kg/m(2) respectively. Responses to appearance and embarrassment correlated strongly and were grouped together. Medical conditions and health concerns account for 52%, appearance and embarrassment for 32%, and poor physical fitness and physical limitation for 16% of first choices. Those who scored 1 for appearance or embarrassment (n=67) had a lower presenting BMI (44 kg/m(2), P=0.03) and all but 1 were female (P<0.001). This group reported more depressive symptoms, poorer mental quality of life and poorer body image preoperatively. Men were more likely than women to be motivated by medical problems (P=0.007). Subjects motivated by a medical condition were more likely to have hypertension or diabetes and less likely to smoke. This group tended to be older. Weight history did not influence motivation. The first choice of motivating factor was not associated with weight outcomes at 1-3 years following surgery.
Health issues dominate the motivation for seeking surgery. Weight outcomes do not appear to be affected by the patient's primary motivating factor.
尚未对寻求肥胖症手术的动机进行研究。作者探讨了患者选择手术的动机,并研究了主要动机因素与体重结果之间的关系。
208名(177名女性:31名男性)未经过挑选的参与者在接受胃束带手术后至少随访了1年,他们完成了一份简短问卷。6条陈述按照从最重要到最不重要的顺序进行1至6分的评分。陈述内容包括外貌、尴尬、疾病状况、健康担忧、身体健康和身体限制。还询问了任何其他因素。
手术前的平均年龄、体重和体重指数分别为41±10岁、129±16千克和46±8千克/平方米。对外貌和尴尬的回答相关性很强,并归为一组。疾病状况和健康担忧占首要选择的52%,外貌和尴尬占32%,身体健康不佳和身体限制占16%。那些在外貌或尴尬方面得1分的人(n = 67)术前的体重指数较低(44千克/平方米,P = 0.03),而且除1人外均为女性(P < 0.001)。该组报告术前有更多的抑郁症状、较差的心理生活质量和较差的身体形象。男性比女性更有可能受疾病问题的驱使(P = 0.007)。受疾病状况驱使的受试者更有可能患有高血压或糖尿病,吸烟的可能性较小。这组人往往年龄较大。体重史不影响动机。首要动机因素的选择与手术后1至3年的体重结果无关。
健康问题是寻求手术的主要动机。体重结果似乎不受患者主要动机因素的影响。