Chick Jonathan, Aschauer Harald, Hornik Kurt
Department of Psychiatry, Royal Edinburgh Hospital, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH10 5HF, Scotland, UK.
Drug Alcohol Depend. 2004 Apr 9;74(1):61-70. doi: 10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2003.11.012.
Patients with a diagnosis of alcohol dependence, detoxified and abstinent for 10-30 days, were randomly allocated to placebo or the serotonin reuptake inhibitor, fluvoxamine (up to 300 mg per day), plus counselling and support. In the intention to treat sample of 493, there was a trend for the fluvoxamine group to do worse than the placebo group on the primary outcome criteria: abstinence; and relapse defined as drinking > or =5 units on an occasion and > or =4 such occasions in a week, or > or =12 units on an occasion (1 unit = 9g ethanol). When typology of alcoholism was assigned by scores on the Tridimensional Personality Questionnaire, Types I and II had similar rates of survival without relapse on placebo (PLC I: 19.3%, n = 135; PLC II: 18.2%, n = 110), but on fluvoxamine Type II did worse than Type I (FLU I: 13.7%, n = 131; FLU II: 6.14%, n = 114) (P < 0.01). When typology was assigned on the basis of age of onset of alcohol problems (< or = age 25, or > age 25), early-onset patients in the fluvoxamine group relapsed more frequently than late-onset patients in that group (no longer significant after adjustment for gender), as did those who commenced regular drinking before age 25 (both with and without adjustment for gender). One explanation for our finding could be that impulsivity in early-onset or Type II patients may be accentuated by serotonin enhancement.
诊断为酒精依赖且已戒酒10至30天的患者被随机分配至安慰剂组或5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂氟伏沙明组(每日剂量高达300毫克),并接受咨询和支持。在493例意向性治疗样本中,在主要结局标准方面,氟伏沙明组有比安慰剂组表现更差的趋势:戒酒情况;以及复发,定义为一次饮酒≥5个单位且一周内≥4次此类情况,或一次饮酒≥12个单位(1个单位=9克乙醇)。当根据三维人格问卷的得分对酒精中毒类型进行分类时,I型和II型在安慰剂组(PLC I:19.3%,n = 135;PLC II:18.2%,n = 110)无复发存活的比例相似,但在氟伏沙明组中,II型比I型表现更差(FLU I:13.7%,n = 131;FLU II:6.14%,n = 114)(P<0.01)。当根据酒精问题开始出现的年龄(≤25岁或>25岁)进行类型分类时,氟伏沙明组中早发患者比该组中的晚发患者复发更频繁(在调整性别后不再显著),25岁前开始经常饮酒的患者也是如此(无论是否调整性别)。对于我们这一发现的一种解释可能是,5-羟色胺增强可能会加剧早发或II型患者的冲动性。