Goettler M, Schneeweiss S, Hasford J
Department of Medical Informatics, Biometry and Epidemiology (IBE), Pharmacoepidemiology Research Group, University of Munich, Germany.
Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf. 1997 Oct;6 Suppl 3:S79-90. doi: 10.1002/(sici)1099-1557(199710)6:3+<s79::aid-pds294>3.3.co;2-f.
Although adverse drug reactions (ADR) are common, there is little knowledge on their direct, indirect and intangible costs. Our study is focused on the direct costs caused by ADR leading to hospital admission. The objective is to quantify the achievable financial benefits if avoidable ADRs were actually prevented by appropriate measures. A literature search on two subjects was done, first on length of stay (LOS) of hospital admissions due to ADR as a proxy measure for direct costs and second on their preventability. Thirteen studies on the length of stay of hospital admissions due to ADR, published between 1975 and 1996, were identified. The median LOS is 8.7 days (lower quartile=8.0 days; upper quartile=12.3 days). Assuming 4.5 million admissions to departments of internal medicine in Germany with a cost of DM 465 per hospital day and a median proportion of 5.8% of medical hospital admission to be due to ADR this yields direct costs of 1050 million DM per year in Germany. A cost table for other regions is provided. Preventability of ADR was the subject of 14 publications that revealed about 30% of all ADRs to be preventable. With regard to Germany this means that 350 million DM per year could be saved by preventing adverse drug reactions. These conservative estimates-no indirect and intangible costs, no ADRs that occur during hospital stay, no ADRs in outpatient care are included-show a considerable economic burden of ADRs. As about 30% of these ADRs are considered avoidable policy-makers are asked to invest more into ADR monitoring and preventive measures. Their benefit would surmount costs and at the same time increase the quality of care.
尽管药物不良反应(ADR)很常见,但人们对其直接、间接和无形的成本却知之甚少。我们的研究聚焦于因ADR导致住院的直接成本。目的是量化如果通过适当措施实际预防了可避免的ADR所能实现的经济收益。针对两个主题进行了文献检索,一是将因ADR导致的住院时间(LOS)作为直接成本的替代指标,二是关于其可预防性。确定了1975年至1996年间发表的13项关于因ADR导致的住院时间的研究。住院时间中位数为8.7天(下四分位数 = 8.0天;上四分位数 = 12.3天)。假设德国内科每年有450万例住院病例,每住院日成本为465德国马克,且因ADR导致的内科住院病例中位数比例为5.8%,这意味着德国每年因ADR产生的直接成本为10.5亿德国马克。还提供了其他地区的成本表。ADR的可预防性是14篇出版物的主题,这些出版物表明所有ADR中约30%是可预防的。就德国而言,这意味着通过预防药物不良反应每年可节省3.5亿德国马克。这些保守估计——不包括间接和无形的成本、不包括住院期间发生的ADR、不包括门诊护理中的ADR——显示了ADR相当大的经济负担。由于这些ADR中约30%被认为是可避免的,因此要求政策制定者在ADR监测和预防措施上投入更多。这样做的好处将超过成本,同时提高护理质量。