Gorwood P
Hôpital Louis Mourier, Service de Psychiatrie, 178, rue des Renouillers, 92700 Colombes, Paris, France.
Encephale. 2004 Mar-Apr;30(2):182-93. doi: 10.1016/s0013-7006(04)95430-9.
An early recognition of bipolar disorders may have an important impact on the prognosis of this disorder according to different mechanisms. Bipolar disorder is nevertheless not easy to detect, the diagnosis being correctly proposed after, in average more than a couple of Years and three different doctors assessments. A short delay before introducing the relevant treatment should help avoiding inappropriate treatments (prescribing, for example, neuroleptics for long periods, antidepressive drugs each time depressive symptoms occurs, absence of treatment despite mood disorders), with their associated negative impact such as mood-switching, rapid cycling or presence of chronic side-effects stigmates. Furthermore, non-treated mood disorders in bipolar disorder are longer, more stigmatizing and may be associated with an increased risk of suicidal behaviour and mortality. Lastly, compliance, an important factor regarding the long term prognosis of bipolar disorder, should be improved when there is a short delay between correct diagnosis and treatment and onset of the disorder. We therefore propose to review the literature for the different pitfalls involved in the diagnosis of bipolar disorder. Non-bipolar mood-disorders are frequently quoted as one of the alternative diagnosis. Hyperthymic temperament, side-effects of prescribed treatments and organic comorbid disorders may be involved. Bipolar disorders have a sex-ratio closer to 1 (men are thus more frequently of the bipolar type in mood-disorders), with earlier age at onset, and more frequent family history of suicidal attempts and bipolar disorder. Schizo-affective disorders are also a major concern regarding the diagnosis of bipolar disorder. This is explained by flat affects sometimes close to anhedonia, presence of a schizoïd personality in bipolar disorder, persecutive hostility that can be considered to be related to irritability rather than a schizophrenic symptom. Rapid cycling, mixed episodes and short euthymia periods may also increase the risk to shift from bipolar to schizophrenia diagnosis. Schizophreniform disorder ("bouffée délirante" aiguë in France) is a frequent form of bipolar disorder onset when major dissociative features are not obvious. The borderline personality is also a problem for the diagnosis of bipolar disorder, some Authors proposing that bipolar disorder is a mood-related personality disorder, sometimes improved by mood-stabilizers. Phasic instead of reactional, weeks and not days-length, clearcut onset and recovery versus non-easy to delimit mood-episodes may help to adjust the diagnosis. Organic disorders may lead to diagnostic confusion, but it is generally proposed that bipolar disorder should be treated the same way, whether or not an organic condition is detected (with special focus on treatment tolerance). Addictive disorders are frequent comorbid conditions in bipolar disorders. Psychostimulants (such as amphetamins or cocaine) intoxications sometimes mimic manic episodes. As these drugs are preferentially chosen by subjects with bipolar disorder, the later diagnosis should be systematically assessed. Puerperal psychosis is a frequent type of onset in female bipolar disorder. The systematic prescription of mood-stabilizers for and after such episode, when mood elation is a major symptom, is generally proposed. Attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder also has unclear border with bipolar disorder, as a quarter of child hyperactivity may be latterly associated with bipolar disorder. The assessment of mood cycling and their follow-up in adulthood may thus be particularly important. Lastly, presence of some anxious disorders may delay the diagnosis of comorbid bipolar disorder.
根据不同机制,早期识别双相情感障碍可能对该疾病的预后产生重要影响。然而,双相情感障碍并不容易被察觉,平均而言,要经过数年时间并由三位不同医生进行评估后才能正确做出诊断。在开始相关治疗前缩短延迟时间应有助于避免不恰当的治疗(例如长期开具抗精神病药物、每次出现抑郁症状时都开具抗抑郁药物、尽管存在情绪障碍却不进行治疗),以及避免这些治疗带来的相关负面影响,如情绪转换、快速循环发作或出现慢性副作用等。此外,双相情感障碍中未经治疗的情绪障碍持续时间更长、更具污名化,并且可能与自杀行为和死亡率增加的风险相关。最后,当正确诊断与治疗之间的延迟较短且疾病发作时,对于双相情感障碍长期预后至关重要的依从性应该会得到改善。因此,我们建议回顾有关双相情感障碍诊断中不同陷阱的文献。非双相情感性心境障碍经常被列为鉴别诊断之一。可能涉及环性心境气质、所开治疗药物的副作用以及器质性共病。双相情感障碍的性别比接近1(因此在心境障碍中男性更常为双相类型),发病年龄较早,且自杀未遂和双相情感障碍的家族史更为常见。精神分裂症性情感障碍也是双相情感障碍诊断中的一个主要问题。这可以通过有时接近快感缺失的平淡情感、双相情感障碍中分裂样人格的存在、可被认为与易激惹而非精神分裂症症状相关的迫害性敌意来解释。快速循环发作、混合发作和短的心境正常期也可能增加从双相情感障碍诊断转变为精神分裂症诊断的风险。精神分裂症样障碍(在法国称为“急性妄想发作”)是双相情感障碍发作的一种常见形式,此时主要的分离性特征不明显。边缘型人格也是双相情感障碍诊断中的一个问题,一些作者提出双相情感障碍是一种与情绪相关的人格障碍,有时可通过心境稳定剂得到改善。呈阶段性而非反应性、持续数周而非数天、起病和恢复明确与难以界定的情绪发作相对比,可能有助于调整诊断。器质性疾病可能导致诊断混淆,但一般认为无论是否检测到器质性疾病,双相情感障碍都应以相同方式治疗(特别关注治疗耐受性)。成瘾性障碍是双相情感障碍中常见的共病情况。精神兴奋剂(如苯丙胺或可卡因)中毒有时会模仿躁狂发作。由于这些药物是双相情感障碍患者优先选择的,所以应系统评估后续诊断。产后精神病是女性双相情感障碍常见的发作类型。一般建议在这种发作期间及之后,当情绪高涨是主要症状时,系统地开具心境稳定剂。注意缺陷多动障碍与双相情感障碍的界限也不明确,因为四分之一的儿童多动可能随后与双相情感障碍相关。因此,对成年期情绪循环的评估及其随访可能尤为重要。最后,某些焦虑症的存在可能会延迟双相情感障碍共病的诊断。