Lev Baruch
Vincent C. Ross Institute for Accounting Research, New York University's Leonard N. Stern School of Business, USA.
Harv Bus Rev. 2004 Jun;82(6):109-16, 138.
Intangible assets--patents and know-how, brands, a skilled workforce, strong customer relationships, software, unique processes and organizational designs, and the like--generate most of a company's growth and shareholder value. Yet extensive research indicates that investors systematically misprice the shares of intangibles-intensive enterprises. Clearly, overpricing wastes capital. But underpricing raises the cost of capital, hamstringing executives in their efforts to take advantage of further growth opportunities. How do you break this vicious cycle? By generating better information about your investments in intangibles, and by disclosing at least some of that data to the capital markets. Getting at that information is easier said than done, however. There are no markets generating visible prices for intellectual capital, brands, or human capital to assist investors in correctly valuing intangibles-intensive companies. And current accounting practices lump funds spent on intangibles with general expenses, so that investors and executives don't even know how much is being invested in them, let alone what a return on those investments might be. At the very least, companies should break out the amounts spent on intangibles and disclose them to the markets. More fundamentally, executives should start thinking of intangibles not as costs but as assets, so that they are recognized as investments whose returns are identified and monitored. The proposals laid down in this article are only a beginning, the author stresses. Corporations and accounting bodies should make systematic efforts to develop information that can reliably reflect the unique attributes of intangible assets. The current serious misallocations of resources should be incentive enough for businesses to join--and even lead--such developments.
无形资产——专利与专有技术、品牌、熟练的劳动力、稳固的客户关系、软件、独特的流程与组织设计等等——创造了公司大部分的增长及股东价值。然而,大量研究表明,投资者系统性地对无形资产密集型企业的股票定价错误。显然,定价过高会浪费资本。但定价过低会提高资本成本,阻碍高管利用进一步的增长机会。如何打破这个恶性循环呢?通过生成关于无形资产投资的更好信息,并向资本市场披露至少部分此类数据。然而,获取这些信息说起来容易做起来难。不存在为智力资本、品牌或人力资本生成可见价格的市场来帮助投资者正确评估无形资产密集型公司。而且当前的会计惯例将用于无形资产的资金与一般费用混在一起,以至于投资者和高管甚至都不知道在无形资产上投入了多少资金,更不用说这些投资的回报可能是多少了。至少,公司应该单独列出用于无形资产的金额并向市场披露。更根本的是,高管们应该开始将无形资产视为资产而非成本,这样它们就会被视为其回报得到识别和监控的投资。作者强调,本文提出的建议只是一个开端。企业和会计机构应该做出系统性努力,以开发能够可靠反映无形资产独特属性的信息。当前严重的资源错配应该足以激励企业参与——甚至引领——此类发展。