Gong Jerald Z, Snyder Matthew J, Lagoo Anand S, Vollmer Robin T, Dash Raj R, Madden John F, Buckley Patrick J, Jones Claudia K
Department of Pathology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina 27710, USA.
Diagn Cytopathol. 2004 Jul;31(1):23-30. doi: 10.1002/dc.20082.
We retrospectively reviewed 74 fine-needle aspiration (FNA) cases of presumptive non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL). All the cases had cytology and core-needle biopsy and 53 cases had concurrent flow cytometric analysis. FNA (cytology and flow cytometry) and core-needle biopsy were evaluated independently. FNA was diagnostic of diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBL) in 25% (13/53) of cases and small B-cell NHL in 15% (8/53) of cases, whereas core-needle biopsy was diagnostic of DLBL in 37% (27/74) of cases and small B-cell NHL in 8% (6/74) of cases. Subclassification of small B-cell NHL was reached in 3/6 cases by core-needle biopsy. Insufficient cases were observed in both FNA (47%; 25/53) and core-needle biopsy (28%; 21/74) groups. With the combination of FNA and core-needle biopsy, diagnostic cases of DLBL increased to 43% (32/74) and insufficient samples were reduced to 16% (12/74). There was no clear advantage in the diagnosis and classification of small B-cell NHL by adding core-needle biopsy to FNA (14%; 10/74). We conclude that core-needle biopsy is a useful adjunct to FNA in the diagnosis of DLBL and shall be encouraged. In small B-cell NHL, core-needle biopsy does not add to the diagnostic ability of FNA. Cases insufficient for diagnosis may be seen in both core-needle biopsy and FNA. A combined approach reduces the number of insufficient cases and is recommended in routine FNA practice.
我们回顾性分析了74例疑似非霍奇金淋巴瘤(NHL)的细针穿刺抽吸(FNA)病例。所有病例均进行了细胞学检查和粗针活检,其中53例同时进行了流式细胞术分析。对FNA(细胞学和流式细胞术)及粗针活检进行独立评估。FNA诊断弥漫性大B细胞淋巴瘤(DLBL)的病例占25%(13/53),诊断小B细胞NHL的病例占15%(8/53);而粗针活检诊断DLBL的病例占37%(27/74),诊断小B细胞NHL的病例占8%(6/74)。粗针活检对6例小B细胞NHL中的3例进行了亚分类。FNA组(47%;25/53)和粗针活检组(28%;21/74)均观察到病例不足的情况。FNA与粗针活检联合应用后,DLBL的诊断病例增加至43%(32/74),样本不足的情况减少至16%(12/74)。对小B细胞NHL而言,在FNA基础上增加粗针活检在诊断和分类方面并无明显优势(14%;10/74)。我们得出结论,粗针活检在DLBL诊断中是FNA的有用辅助手段,应予以鼓励。对于小B细胞NHL,粗针活检并未增强FNA的诊断能力。粗针活检和FNA均可能出现诊断不足的病例。联合方法可减少诊断不足的病例数量,建议在FNA常规操作中采用。