Kapp D S, Cox R S, Barnett T A, Ben-Yosef R
Department of Radiation Oncology, Stanford University School of Medicine, CA 94305.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1992;24(2):261-77. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(92)90681-7.
A Phase I/II study was undertaken to investigate the efficacy and side effects of combined hyperthermia and radiation therapy in the management of presumed or known microscopic residual tumors. Between February 1985 and March 1991, 262 fields in 89 patients with local-regional recurrent breast cancer were treated with externally administered hyperthermia and radiation therapy. Thirty-eight fields were treated for microscopic residual disease following excisional biopsy of nodular recurrences and 224 fields were treated electively for areas at high risk for local recurrences adjacent to fields with macroscopic residual disease. Mechanically mapped temperatures were monitored throughout the field in all treatments. All patients had at least one follow-up evaluation at three weeks or more following completion of treatment. The majority of the fields were in patients who had had extensive prior therapy including radiation therapy (54%), chemotherapy (71%), and hormonal therapy (51%). All fields received hyperthermia (1-6 treatments: average 1.74) and radiation therapy (average dose: 42.4 Gy); concurrent hormonal therapy was administered in 37% of the treatments and no fields received concurrent chemotherapy. The treatments were well tolerated, no life-threatening complications were noted. Averages for all fields of the minimum, maximum, and average measured interstitial temperatures were 40.2 degrees C, 45.3 degrees C, and 42.8 degrees C, respectively. The three-year actuarial local-control rate for all 262 treated fields was 68%. Parameters characterizing the initial breast cancer, the patient and tumor at the time of hyperthermia, and the treatment were studied in univariate and multivariate analysis for correlation with duration of local control within the hyperthermia treatment field. Parameters in the best five covariate model correlating with the duration of local control included: estrogen receptor status of the initial breast cancer; initial T-stage; time from initial breast cancer to first failure; age at hyperthermia; and concurrent radiation dose (p-value for model less than 0.000001). Six covariate models adding anatomic site of disease, field type, mean minimum temperatures, and mean percent temperatures greater than or equal to 40 degrees C all resulted in improved models. Randomized controlled studies stratifying for these pretreatment parameters are felt warranted to confirm the value of adjuvant hyperthermia in the elective treatment of areas of high risk for local-regional recurrent breast cancer and in fields following surgical excision of recurrent disease, particularly in patients in whom full dose radiation therapy cannot be safely administered.
开展了一项I/II期研究,以调查热疗与放射治疗联合应用于处理假定或已知微小残留肿瘤的疗效和副作用。1985年2月至1991年3月期间,对89例局部区域复发性乳腺癌患者的262个部位进行了体外热疗和放射治疗。38个部位在结节性复发切除活检后针对微小残留病灶进行治疗,224个部位针对与有肉眼可见残留病灶区域相邻的局部复发高危区域进行选择性治疗。在所有治疗过程中对整个区域的机械映射温度进行监测。所有患者在治疗完成后至少有一次为期三周或更长时间的随访评估。大多数部位的患者此前接受过广泛治疗,包括放射治疗(54%)、化疗(71%)和激素治疗(51%)。所有部位均接受了热疗(1 - 6次治疗:平均1.74次)和放射治疗(平均剂量:42.4 Gy);37%的治疗中同时给予了激素治疗,没有部位接受同步化疗。治疗耐受性良好,未观察到危及生命的并发症。所有部位测量的最低、最高和平均间质温度的平均值分别为40.2℃、45.3℃和42.8℃。所有262个治疗部位的三年精算局部控制率为68%。对表征初始乳腺癌、热疗时的患者和肿瘤以及治疗的参数进行单变量和多变量分析,以研究与热疗治疗区域内局部控制持续时间的相关性。与局部控制持续时间相关的最佳五变量模型中的参数包括:初始乳腺癌的雌激素受体状态;初始T分期;从初始乳腺癌到首次复发的时间;热疗时的年龄;以及同步放射剂量(模型的p值小于0.000001)。添加疾病解剖部位、部位类型、平均最低温度以及平均温度大于或等于40℃的百分比的六个变量模型均使模型得到改进。认为有必要进行针对这些预处理参数分层的随机对照研究,以证实辅助热疗在选择性治疗局部区域复发性乳腺癌高危区域以及复发病灶手术切除后的部位中的价值,特别是在无法安全给予全剂量放射治疗的患者中。