Hehr T, Lamprecht U, Glocker S, Classen J, Paulsen F, Budach W, Bamberg M
Department of Radiation Oncology, Eberhard-Karls-University of Tübingen, Germany.
Int J Hyperthermia. 2001 Jul-Aug;17(4):291-301. doi: 10.1080/02656730110049538.
This retrospective analysis investigated the effectiveness and side-effects of combined hyperthermia and radiation therapy in locally recurrent breast cancer after primary modified radical mastectomy. The aim of the thermoradiotherapy was to reduce the substantial risk of symptomatic chest wall disease.
Between May 1995-August 1998, 39 extensively pre-treated women with progressive locoregional chest wall tumours were treated with local radiofrequency hyperthermia, given twice a week immediately before radiotherapy. Sixty-two per cent of the patients had received previous radiotherapy, with a median dose of 50 Gy, 64% had received chemotherapy, 36% hormonal therapy, and 13% local therapy with miltefosin, respectively. Nine patients were treated for microscopic residual disease after local tumour excision (R1-resection) and 30 patients for gross macroscopic nodular recurrences. Twenty-seven patients had two adjacent hyperthermia fields at the ipsilateral chest wall to cover the whole irradiation area. Each field received a median of seven local hyperthermia sessions (range 2-12, average 5.6 sessions) just before radiation therapy, with a median dose of 60 Gy (range 30-68 Gy). The monitored maximum(average) and average(average) epicutaneous temperatures were 42.1 degrees C and 41.0 degrees C, respectively. Maximum(average) and average(average) intratumoural temperatures of 43.0 degrees C and 41.1 degrees C, respectively, were achieved in nine chest wall recurrences with intratumoural temperature probes. Concurrent hormonal therapy was administered in 48%, and concurrent chemotherapy in 10% of patients.
Median overall survival time was 28 months (Kaplan Meier), with 71% and 54% of patients living 1 and 2 years after thermoradiotherapy. The median time to local failure has not been reached, local tumour control after 2 years being 53%. Actuarial 1 and 2 year local tumour controls for microscopic residual disease were 89%, and for macroscopic nodular recurrences 71% and 46%, respectively (p = 0.09). Actuarial 1 and 2 year local tumour controls after treatment with a total dose of less than 60 Gy were 51% and 38%, respectively, and, after a total dose greater than 60 Gy, 84% and 60% (p = 0.01), respectively. Actuarial 1 year local tumour control was 92% after complete tumour remission, versus 57% after partial remission (p = 0.002). Three of the 39 patients died of cancer en cuirasse, 13 patients due to distant metastases. Acute thermoradiotherapy related erythema, dry desquamation and moist desquamation were seen in 28.2%, 30.7%, and 30.7% of patients, respectively. Soft tissue necrosis occurred in two patients with previous post-operative delayed wound healing, and in one patient above a silicon implant.
This study showed that, in extensively pre-treated patients with locally recurrent breast cancer, local tumour control after thermoradiotherapy depended on tumour resectability, response of macroscopic tumour to thermoradiotherapy, and total irradiation dose.
本回顾性分析研究了原发性改良根治性乳房切除术后局部复发性乳腺癌患者接受热疗与放射治疗联合应用的有效性及副作用。热放疗的目的是降低有症状的胸壁疾病的重大风险。
1995年5月至1998年8月期间,39例经过广泛预处理的局部区域胸壁肿瘤进展的女性患者接受了局部射频热疗,每周两次,在放疗前即刻进行。62%的患者曾接受过放疗,中位剂量为50 Gy;64%的患者接受过化疗,36%接受过激素治疗,13%接受过米替福新局部治疗。9例患者在局部肿瘤切除术后(R1切除)接受了微小残留病灶治疗,30例患者接受了肉眼可见的大结节复发治疗。27例患者在同侧胸壁有两个相邻的热疗区域以覆盖整个照射区域。每个区域在放疗前接受了中位7次局部热疗(范围2 - 12次,平均5.6次),中位放疗剂量为60 Gy(范围30 - 68 Gy)。监测到的最大(平均)和平均(平均)表皮温度分别为42.1℃和41.0℃。在9例有瘤内温度探头的胸壁复发患者中,瘤内最大(平均)和平均(平均)温度分别为43.0℃和41.1℃。48%的患者接受了同步激素治疗,10%的患者接受了同步化疗。
中位总生存时间为28个月(Kaplan Meier法),热放疗后1年和2年存活的患者分别为71%和54%。局部失败的中位时间尚未达到,2年后局部肿瘤控制率为53%。微小残留病灶的1年和2年精算局部肿瘤控制率分别为89%,肉眼可见大结节复发的分别为71%和46%(p = 0.09)。总剂量小于60 Gy治疗后的1年和2年精算局部肿瘤控制率分别为51%和38%,总剂量大于60 Gy后分别为84%和60%(p = 0.01)。肿瘤完全缓解后的1年精算局部肿瘤控制率为92%,部分缓解后为57%(p = 0.002)。39例患者中有3例死于铠甲状癌,13例死于远处转移。热放疗相关的急性红斑、干性脱皮和湿性脱皮分别见于28.2%、30.7%和30.7%的患者。2例既往术后伤口愈合延迟的患者以及1例硅植入物上方的患者发生了软组织坏死。
本研究表明,在经过广泛预处理的局部复发性乳腺癌患者中,热放疗后的局部肿瘤控制取决于肿瘤的可切除性、肉眼可见肿瘤对热放疗的反应以及总照射剂量。