Lande R G
Department of Psychiatry, Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Washington, DC.
Mil Med. 1992 Aug;157(8):392-7.
This article provides guidance in performing clinical psychiatric evaluations of the criminally accused. The interface between the law and psychiatry raises difficult dilemmas. Through a review of military regulations and relevant case law, suggestions are provided to enhance the clinician's control, quality, and value of contribution. The clinician's need for complete disclosure from the accused soldier, in order to ensure a thorough forensic assessment, may conflict with legal concerns. The accused and the military justice system must consider specific issues, such as confidentiality and compliance. This article discusses the practical ramifications and implications of these issues.
本文为对刑事被告进行临床精神病学评估提供指导。法律与精神病学之间的交叉引发了棘手的困境。通过回顾军事法规和相关判例法,提出了一些建议,以增强临床医生的把控能力、评估质量及贡献价值。临床医生需要被告士兵进行全面披露,以确保进行彻底的法医评估,这可能与法律关注点产生冲突。被告及军事司法系统必须考虑一些具体问题,如保密性和合规性。本文讨论了这些问题的实际影响和后果。