Hilmi O J, Bolton P, Ahsan F, Nunez D A
Department of Otolaryngology and Head and Neck Surgery, Grampian University Hospitals Trust, Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
J Laryngol Otol. 2004 Jun;118(6):409-12. doi: 10.1258/002221504323219491.
Specialist training at the registrar grade in the United Kingdom has undergone significant change in the recent past. One of the effects has been a reduction in the length of time spent in training. This and the application of the European working time directive have the potential to reduce trainees' surgical exposure. The proportion of tympanic membrane procedures performed by reconstructive otolaryngology registrars in the Grampian University hospitals was audited to monitor the impact of these changes. Case notes of all patients who underwent myringoplasty or tympanoplasty between July 1998 and June 1999 were analysed retrospectively. Details of the surgeons' grade were recorded. The proportion of myringoplasties performed by registrars as determined by the Royal College of Surgeons of England National Comparative Audit survey, carried out in 1995 before the widespread implementation of recommended changes in otolaryngology registrar training, was set as the gold standard. In the period July 1998-1999 registrars had performed fewer myringoplasties than the standard, 17 per cent versus 34.2 per cent respectively (p = 0.035). A strategy to increase registrar exposure to myringoplasty surgery was then adopted by the department and the proportion of myringoplasties performed by registrars re-audited prospectively. The proportion of myringoplasties undertaken by registrars increased in the period January 2001 to July 2001 compared to July 1998-1999, 53 per cent versus 17 per cent respectively (p < 0.0007). Changes in working practice can address shortfalls in registrars' exposure to surgical procedures.
英国近期专科住院医师阶段的专科培训发生了重大变化。其中一个影响是培训时长缩短。这以及欧洲工作时间指令的实施有可能减少住院医师的手术实操机会。对格兰扁大学医院重建耳鼻喉科住院医师所做鼓膜手术的比例进行了审核,以监测这些变化的影响。对1998年7月至1999年6月期间所有接受鼓膜成形术或鼓室成形术患者的病历进行了回顾性分析。记录了外科医生的级别详情。将1995年在耳鼻喉科住院医师培训推荐改革广泛实施之前进行的英格兰皇家外科医师学院全国比较审核调查所确定的住院医师实施鼓膜成形术的比例,设定为黄金标准。在1998年7月至1999年期间,住院医师实施的鼓膜成形术比标准比例少,分别为17%和34.2%(p = 0.035)。随后该科室采取了一项增加住院医师鼓膜成形术实操机会的策略,并对住院医师实施鼓膜成形术的比例进行了前瞻性重新审核。与1998年7月至1999年相比,2001年1月至2001年7月期间住院医师实施鼓膜成形术的比例有所增加,分别为53%和17%(p < 0.0007)。工作实践的改变可以弥补住院医师手术实操机会的不足。