Gordeliy V I, Chernov N I
IBI-2, Structural Biology, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Germany.
Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr. 1997 Jul 1;53(Pt 4):377-84. doi: 10.1107/S0907444997000826.
Neutron diffraction combined with the deuterium-labelled molecular groups of biological and model membrane components allows one to detect with high accuracy the structure of these objects. Experiments of this kind are only possible at unique high-flux neutron sources, and the planning of neutron-diffraction experiments must take into account some special requirements primarily related to the duration of the experiment and the accuracy of estimation of membrane structure parameters as a result of finite time of the measurements. This paper deals with the question of statistical accuracy of the position x(0) and width v of the distribution of deuterium labels in membranes along the normal of their plane, which are determined in a neutron diffraction experiment. It is shown that the accuracy of x(0) and v estimation does not depend on membrane constitution. It is dependent only on the scattering amplitude of the deuterium label, the label position x(0) and the distribution width v. Analytic calculations show that the statistical errors Deltax(0) and Deltav are inversely proportional to the scattering amplitude of the label and, as usual, to the square root of measurement time. The question of Deltax0 and Deltav dependence on the number of structure factors used in the calculations of x(0) and v is also studied. It is shown that, the accuracy of x(0) estimation is approximately constant with down to four structure factors used, and, with the number of the factors below four, it deteriorates drastically. Analogous is the behaviour of Deltav(h(max)) relation with one exception: abrupt deterioration of the accuracy occurs beginning with five structure factors used. One does not have to measure the highest diffraction reflections which takes a much longer time compared with the first ones. It is an important result. All the problems mentioned above have also been considered for the case of two different deuterium labels in membranes.
中子衍射与生物及模型膜成分的氘标记分子基团相结合,能够高精度地检测这些物体的结构。此类实验只能在独特的高通量中子源上进行,并且中子衍射实验的规划必须考虑一些特殊要求,这些要求主要与实验持续时间以及由于测量时间有限而导致的膜结构参数估计精度有关。本文探讨了在中子衍射实验中确定的膜中氘标记沿其平面法线方向分布的位置(x(0))和宽度(v)的统计精度问题。结果表明,(x(0))和(v)估计的精度不取决于膜的组成。它仅取决于氘标记的散射振幅、标记位置(x(0))和分布宽度(v)。解析计算表明,统计误差(\Delta x(0))和(\Delta v)与标记的散射振幅成反比,并且与通常情况一样,与测量时间的平方根成反比。还研究了(\Delta x_0)和(\Delta v)对计算(x(0))和(v)时所用结构因子数量的依赖性。结果表明,使用多达四个结构因子时,(x(0))估计的精度大致恒定,而当因子数量低于四个时,精度会急剧下降。(\Delta v(h_{max}))关系的行为类似,但有一个例外:从使用五个结构因子开始,精度会突然下降。不必测量最高衍射反射,与第一个反射相比,这需要更长的时间。这是一个重要的结果。对于膜中两种不同氘标记的情况,也考虑了上述所有问题。