Zakrison Tanya L, Hamel Paul A, Hwang Stephen W
Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Urban Health. 2004 Dec;81(4):596-605. doi: 10.1093/jurban/jth143.
Although the health impact of patients' trust in physicians has been well documented, less is known about the possible health effects of trust in police or paramedics. Homeless people frequently interact with police officers and paramedics, and these experiences may affect their health and future willingness to seek emergency assistance. We examined homeless people's self-reported interactions with police and paramedics in Toronto, Canada, and their level of trust in these emergency service providers. In a sample of 160 shelter users, 61% had interacted with police in the last 12 months, and 37% had interacted with paramedics (P = .0001). The proportion of subjects who expressed willingness to call police in an emergency was significantly lower than those willing to call paramedics in an emergency (69% vs. 92%, P = .0001). On a Likert scale ranging from a minimum of 0 to a maximum of 5, trust levels were lower in police than in paramedics (median level 3 vs. 5, P = .0001). Among shelter users, 9% (95% confidence interval [CI], 5% to 14%) reported an assault by a police officer in the last year, and 0% (95% CI, 0% to 4%) reported an assault by a paramedic. These findings showed that homeless people have much lower levels of trust in police than paramedics. Reports of negative interactions with police are not uncommon, and homeless people's perceptions of the police may pose a barrier to seeking emergency assistance. Further research is needed for objective characterization of homeless people's interactions with police officers and the potential health implications of low levels of trust in the police.
尽管患者对医生的信任对健康的影响已有充分记录,但对于信任警察或护理人员可能产生的健康影响却知之甚少。无家可归者经常与警察和护理人员打交道,而这些经历可能会影响他们的健康以及未来寻求紧急援助的意愿。我们调查了加拿大多伦多无家可归者与警察和护理人员的自我报告互动情况,以及他们对这些紧急服务提供者的信任程度。在160名收容所使用者的样本中,61%的人在过去12个月内与警察有过互动,37%的人与护理人员有过互动(P = 0.0001)。表示愿意在紧急情况下报警的受试者比例显著低于愿意呼叫护理人员的比例(69%对92%,P = 0.0001)。在从0到5的李克特量表上,对警察的信任程度低于护理人员(中位数水平为3对5,P = 0.0001)。在收容所使用者中,9%(95%置信区间[CI],5%至14%)报告在去年遭到警察袭击,0%(95%CI,0%至4%)报告遭到护理人员袭击。这些发现表明,无家可归者对警察的信任程度远低于护理人员。与警察的负面互动报告并不罕见,无家可归者对警察的看法可能会成为寻求紧急援助的障碍。需要进一步研究以客观描述无家可归者与警察的互动情况以及对警察信任度低可能产生的健康影响。