Magkos Faidon, Kavouras Stavros A
Laboratory of Nutrition and Clinical Dietetics, Department of Nutrition and Dietetics, Harokopio University, Athens, Greece.
Sports Med. 2004;34(13):871-89. doi: 10.2165/00007256-200434130-00002.
Preparations containing caffeine and ephedrine have become increasingly popular among sportspersons in recent years as a means to enhance athletic performance. This is due to a slowly accumulating body of evidence suggesting that combination of the two drugs may be more efficacious than each one alone. Caffeine is a compound with documented ergogenicity in various exercise modalities, while ephedrine and related alkaloids have not been shown, as yet, to result in any significant performance improvements. Caffeine-ephedrine mixtures, however, have been reported in several instances to confer a greater ergogenic benefit than either drug by itself. Although data are limited and heterogeneous in nature to allow for reaching consensus, the increase in performance is a rather uniform finding as it has been observed during submaximal steady-state aerobic exercise, short- and long-distance running, maximal and supramaximal anaerobic cycling, as well as weight lifting. From the metabolic point of view, combined ingestion of caffeine and ephedrine has been observed to increase blood glucose and lactate concentrations during exercise, wheareas qualitatively similar effects on lipid fuels (free fatty acids and glycerol) are less pronounced. In parallel, epinephrine and dopamine concentrations are significantly increased, wheareas the effects on norepinephrine are less clear. With respect to pulmonary gas exchange during short-term intense exercise, no physiologically significant effects have been reported following ingestion of caffeine, ephedrine or their combination. Yet, during longer and/or more demanding efforts, some sporadic enhancements have indeed been shown. On the other hand, a relatively consistent cardiovascular manifestation of the latter preparation is an increase in heart rate, in addition to that caused by exercise alone. Finally, evidence to date strongly suggests that caffeine and ephedrine combined are quite effective in decreasing the rating of perceived exertion and this seems to be independent of the type of activity being performed. In general, our knowledge and understanding of the physiological, metabolic and performance-enhancing effects of caffeine-ephedrine mixtures are still in their infancy. Research in this field is probably hampered by sound ethical concerns that preclude administration of potentially hazardous substances to human volunteers. In contrast, while it is certainly true that caffeine and especially ephedrine have been associated with several acute adverse effects on health, athletes do not seem to be concerned with these, as long as they perceive that their performance will improve. In light of the fact that caffeine and ephedra alkaloids, but not ephedrine itself, have been removed from the list of banned substances, their use in sports can be expected to rise considerably in the foreseeable future. Caffeine-ephedra mixtures may thus become one of most popular ergogenic aids in the years to come and while they may indeed prove to be one of the most effective ones, and probably one of the few legal ones, whether they also turn out to be one of the most dangerous ones awaits to be witnessed.
近年来,含有咖啡因和麻黄碱的制剂在运动员中越来越受欢迎,被视为提高运动成绩的一种手段。这是因为越来越多的证据表明,这两种药物联合使用可能比单独使用更有效。咖啡因是一种在各种运动方式中都有明确促力作用的化合物,而麻黄碱及相关生物碱目前尚未显示能显著提高运动成绩。然而,有报道称,在多个案例中,咖啡因 - 麻黄碱混合物比单独使用任何一种药物都具有更大的促力益处。尽管现有数据有限且性质各异,难以达成共识,但运动成绩提高这一现象相当一致,已在次最大稳态有氧运动、短跑和长跑、最大和超最大无氧骑行以及举重运动中观察到。从代谢角度来看,已观察到联合摄入咖啡因和麻黄碱会在运动期间增加血糖和乳酸浓度,而对脂质燃料(游离脂肪酸和甘油)的类似定性影响则不太明显。同时,肾上腺素和多巴胺浓度会显著增加,而对去甲肾上腺素的影响则不太明确。关于短期剧烈运动期间的肺气体交换,摄入咖啡因、麻黄碱或其组合后未报告有任何生理上显著的影响。然而,在更长时间和/或要求更高的运动中,确实显示出一些零星的增强作用。另一方面,后一种制剂相对一致的心血管表现是心率增加,这是除了运动本身引起的心率增加之外的。最后,迄今为止的证据强烈表明,咖啡因和麻黄碱联合使用在降低主观用力感觉评分方面非常有效,而且这似乎与所进行的活动类型无关。总体而言,我们对咖啡因 - 麻黄碱混合物的生理、代谢和提高运动成绩作用的认识和理解仍处于起步阶段。该领域的研究可能受到合理伦理问题的阻碍,这些问题使得无法向人类志愿者施用潜在有害物质。相比之下,虽然咖啡因尤其是麻黄碱确实与一些对健康的急性不良反应有关,但运动员似乎并不在意这些,只要他们认为自己的成绩会提高。鉴于咖啡因和麻黄生物碱(而非麻黄碱本身)已从禁用物质清单中删除,预计在可预见的未来它们在体育界的使用将大幅增加。因此,咖啡因 - 麻黄混合物可能在未来几年成为最受欢迎的促力辅助剂之一,虽然它们可能确实被证明是最有效的之一,而且可能是少数合法的之一,但它们是否也会成为最危险的之一还有待观察。